Hall Patricia, von Koch Lena, Wang Xu, Lennon Olive
iPASTAR Collaborative Doctoral Award Programme, RCSI Division of Population Health Sciences, RCSI University of Medicine and Health Sciences, D02 H903 Dublin, Ireland.
School of Public Health, Physiotherapy and Sports Science, Health Science Centre, University College Dublin, D04 C7X2 Belfield, Ireland.
Healthcare (Basel). 2022 Mar 4;10(3):481. doi: 10.3390/healthcare10030481.
The Stroke Action Plan for Europe (2018-2030) calls for national-level secondary prevention plans that address lifestyle, in addition to prevention medications and surgical interventions. This scoping review examines national stroke care guideline and audit documents across WHO regions to identify non-pharmacological, non-surgical stroke secondary prevention recommendations and associated performance indicators. Using a snowballing methodology, 27 guideline documents met the inclusion criteria. Sixteen (59%) detailed, non-pharmacological, non-surgical stroke secondary prevention-addressing known, modifiable population attributable risk factors, of physical inactivity (N = 11), smoking (N = 11), unsafe alcohol consumption (N = 10), diet (N = 8), weight (N = 5), stress (N = 4) and depression (N = 2). Strategies recommended to address these risk factors were: assessment of stroke risk/risk factors (N = 4); provision of advice and information on reducing lifestyle related risk (N = 16); education and counselling for lifestyle behaviour change (N = 8) and onward referral for specialist management of risk (N = 4). Of the nine stroke audits/registries identified, only three (33%) included non-pharmacological, non-surgical quality indicators of documented provision of advice or information on the following: general lifestyle (N = 2); smoking cessation for current smokers (N = 2); reduction in alcohol consumption, where relevant (N = 1), exercise participation (N = 1) and diet (N = 1). Preventive quality indicators addressing the management of weight, stress or depression were absent. This review highlights current gaps in optimal stroke secondary prevention recommendations and their implementation.
《欧洲中风行动计划(2018 - 2030年)》呼吁制定国家级二级预防计划,除了预防用药和手术干预外,还要涉及生活方式。本范围综述考察了世卫组织各区域的国家中风护理指南和审核文件,以确定非药物、非手术的中风二级预防建议及相关绩效指标。采用滚雪球法,27份指南文件符合纳入标准。16份(59%)详细阐述了非药物、非手术的中风二级预防,涉及已知的、可改变的人群归因风险因素,包括身体活动不足(11份)、吸烟(11份)、不安全饮酒(10份)、饮食(8份)、体重(5份)、压力(4份)和抑郁(2份)。针对这些风险因素推荐的策略包括:评估中风风险/风险因素(4份);提供关于降低生活方式相关风险的建议和信息(16份);针对生活方式行为改变的教育和咨询(8份)以及将风险转介给专科医生进行管理(4份)。在确定的9份中风审核/登记文件中,只有3份(33%)纳入了非药物、非手术的质量指标,记录了关于以下方面的建议或信息的提供情况:一般生活方式(2份);当前吸烟者戒烟(2份);在相关情况下减少酒精消费(1份)、参与锻炼(1份)和饮食(1份)。缺乏针对体重、压力或抑郁管理的预防性质量指标。本综述突出了当前在最佳中风二级预防建议及其实施方面的差距。