Kaiser Permanente Division of Research, Oakland, CA.
CREST Network, Oakland, CA.
Perm J. 2021 Jul 28;25:20.303. doi: 10.7812/TPP/20.303.
The evidence for the effectiveness of outpatient treatment of low-risk patients with acute pulmonary embolism (PE) continues to mount. However, lack of definitional clarity may hinder understanding of this emerging management strategy and impede translation into clinical practice. We describe the range of definitions provided in the primary outpatient PE literature.
We undertook a narrative review of the English-language medical literature indexed in PubMed and Embase through the end of 2019. We identified studies of outpatient treatment of patients with acute PE.
Fifty-one studies met our criteria. All studies provided some degree of definition of "outpatient," even if implicit or broad. Forty-six studies (90%) reported 1 or 2 sites of patient discharge (or departure) to home: emergency department (ED)/ambulatory care unit (n = 31), inpatient ward (n = 13), and secondary care clinic (n = 8). Of the 31 ED-based studies, 9 (29%) delimited duration of care (from < 24 to < 48 hours). All inpatient studies placed an outer boundary on the time to discharge within their definition of outpatient care.
Definitions of outpatient care in the PE literature vary considerably. The sites, duration, and intensity of care involved in outpatient PE management prior to home discharge range from comprehensive specialty clinic care to an ED evaluation, sometimes coupled with 1 to 5 days of additional inpatient care. Research on the outpatient management of acute PE would benefit from greater definitional clarity as clinicians, departments, and health systems seek to translate this research into real-world clinical practice.
越来越多的证据表明,对低危急性肺栓塞(PE)患者进行门诊治疗是有效的。然而,定义不明确可能会阻碍对这一新兴管理策略的理解,并阻碍其转化为临床实践。我们描述了初级门诊 PE 文献中提供的一系列定义。
我们对 2019 年底在 PubMed 和 Embase 中索引的英文医学文献进行了叙述性综述。我们确定了门诊治疗急性 PE 患者的研究。
符合我们标准的有 51 项研究。所有研究都对“门诊”进行了一定程度的定义,即使是隐含的或宽泛的定义。46 项研究(90%)报告了 1 或 2 个患者出院(或离开)回家的地点:急诊科/门诊(n=31)、住院病房(n=13)和二级保健诊所(n=8)。在 31 项基于急诊科的研究中,有 9 项(29%)限定了护理时间(从<24 小时到<48 小时)。所有住院研究都在门诊护理的定义范围内规定了出院时间的上限。
PE 文献中的门诊护理定义差异很大。在家庭出院前,门诊 PE 管理所涉及的护理场所、持续时间和强度从综合性专科诊所护理到急诊科评估不等,有时还需要 1 至 5 天的额外住院护理。随着临床医生、科室和卫生系统寻求将这一研究转化为现实世界的临床实践,急性 PE 门诊管理的研究将受益于更大的定义清晰度。