Genon Sarah, Eickhoff Simon B, Kharabian Shahrzad
Institute of Systems Neuroscience, Heinrich Heine University Düsseldorf, Düsseldorf, Germany.
Institute of Neuroscience and Medicine (INM-7), Research Centre Jülich, Jülich, Germany.
Nat Rev Neurosci. 2022 May;23(5):307-318. doi: 10.1038/s41583-022-00584-7. Epub 2022 Apr 1.
What are the brain structural correlates of interindividual differences in behaviour? More than a decade ago, advances in structural MRI opened promising new avenues to address this question. The initial wave of research then progressively led to substantial conceptual and methodological shifts, and a replication crisis unveiled the limitations of traditional approaches, which involved searching for associations between local measurements of neuroanatomy and behavioural variables in small samples of healthy individuals. Given these methodological issues and growing scepticism regarding the idea of one-to-one mapping of psychological constructs to brain regions, new perspectives emerged. These not only embrace the multivariate nature of brain structure-behaviour relationships and promote generalizability but also embrace the representation of the relationships between brain structure and behavioural data by latent dimensions of interindividual variability. Here, we examine the past and present of the study of brain structure-behaviour associations in healthy populations and address current challenges and open questions for future investigations.
行为个体差异的脑结构关联因素有哪些?十多年前,结构磁共振成像(MRI)技术的进步为解决这一问题开辟了充满希望的新途径。随后的首轮研究逐渐引发了重大的概念和方法转变,一场复制危机揭示了传统方法的局限性,传统方法涉及在少量健康个体样本中寻找神经解剖局部测量值与行为变量之间的关联。鉴于这些方法学问题以及人们对心理结构与脑区一对一映射观点的日益怀疑,新的视角应运而生。这些视角不仅包含脑结构 - 行为关系的多变量性质并促进可推广性,还通过个体间变异性的潜在维度来体现脑结构与行为数据之间关系的表征。在此,我们审视了健康人群脑结构 - 行为关联研究的过去与现状,并探讨了当前面临的挑战以及未来研究中有待解决的开放性问题。