Cangel Ugur, Sirekbasan Serhat, Polat Erdal
Department of Cardiovascular Surgery, Medical Faculty, Bahcesehir University, Istanbul, Turkey.
Department of Medical Laboratory Techniques, Eldivan Vocational School of Health Services, Çankırı Karatekin University, Çankırı, Turkey.
Evid Based Complement Alternat Med. 2022 Mar 29;2022:8148298. doi: 10.1155/2022/8148298. eCollection 2022.
Even for very successful peripheral revascularization therapy, treatment is not complete until the ulcerative, gangrenous, and infected wound is closed. This study was performed and compared the outcomes of vacuum-assisted closure (VAC) and maggot debridement therapy (MDT) following peripheral revascularization to accelerate the wound healing process.
We did a prospective randomized clinical trial between January 1, 2014, and June 21, 2019. This study included 72 patients (63 males and nine females). Balloon angioplasty was performed in 21 patients (29.2%), peripheral bypass in 39 (54.2%), and both balloon angioplasty and revascularization (hybrid) surgery in 12 (16.7%). Thirty-three patients (45.8%) received 15 VAC therapy sessions for a month. Therapy progress was monitored at 48 h intervals, and wound debridement was performed. Thirty-nine patients (54.2%) received an average of six larval therapy sessions for a month. Groups were compared with the test, and a statistically significant difference was found ( < 0.001).
In the VAC therapy group ( = 33), 14 patients (42.4%) had their feet amputated, 5 (15.1%) had a toe amputated, and 4 (12.1%) had all of their toes amputated. A skin graft was performed on four patients (12.1%) who developed granulation tissue. The wounds of six patients (18.2%) undergoing VAC therapy healed. In the larval therapy group ( = 39), the wounds healed in 36 patients (92.3%), and 3 (7.7%) had a toe amputated.
Larval therapy was shown to be more effective than VAC therapy for the treatment of postrevascularization ischemic wounds. Thus, larval therapy can be used as an effective biological treatment method when major amputation is not required.
即使对于非常成功的外周血管重建治疗,在溃疡性、坏疽性和感染性伤口闭合之前,治疗仍未完成。进行本研究并比较外周血管重建术后负压封闭引流(VAC)和蛆虫清创疗法(MDT)的效果,以加速伤口愈合过程。
我们在2014年1月1日至2019年6月21日期间进行了一项前瞻性随机临床试验。本研究纳入72例患者(63例男性和9例女性)。21例患者(29.2%)接受了球囊血管成形术,39例(54.2%)接受了外周旁路手术,12例(16.7%)接受了球囊血管成形术和血管重建(杂交)手术。33例患者(45.8%)接受了为期1个月的15次VAC治疗。每隔48小时监测治疗进展,并进行伤口清创。39例患者(54.2%)平均接受了为期1个月的6次幼虫治疗。采用t检验对两组进行比较,发现差异有统计学意义(P<0.001)。
在VAC治疗组(n=33)中,14例患者(42.4%)足部被截肢,5例(15.1%)足趾被截肢,4例(12.1%)所有足趾被截肢。4例(12.1%)出现肉芽组织的患者接受了植皮手术。6例(18.2%)接受VAC治疗的患者伤口愈合。在幼虫治疗组(n=39)中,36例患者(92.3%)伤口愈合,3例(7.7%)足趾被截肢。
对于血管重建术后缺血性伤口的治疗,幼虫疗法比VAC疗法更有效。因此,在不需要进行大截肢时,幼虫疗法可作为一种有效的生物治疗方法。