Department of Clinical and Health Psychology, University of Florida, Gainesville, PO Box 100165, Florida, FL, 32653, USA.
Division of Neuropsychology, Mayo Clinic, Scottsdale, AZ, USA.
Neurotherapeutics. 2022 Jan;19(1):117-131. doi: 10.1007/s13311-022-01225-8. Epub 2022 Apr 12.
Comparative effectiveness of behavioral interventions to mitigate the impacts of degeneration-based cognitive decline is not well understood. To better address this gap, we summarize the studies from the Healthy Action to Benefit Independence & Thinking (HABIT®) program, developed for persons with mild cognitive impairment (pwMCI) and their partners. HABIT® includes memory compensation training, computerized cognitive training (CCT), yoga, patient and partner support groups, and wellness education. Studies cited include (i) a survey of clinical program completers to establish outcome priorities; (ii) a five-arm, multi-site cluster randomized, comparative effectiveness trial; (iii) and a three-arm ancillary study. PwMCI quality of life (QoL) was considered a high-priority outcome. Across datasets, findings suggest that quality of life was most affected in groups where wellness education was included and CCT withheld. Wellness education also had greater impact on mood than CCT. Yoga had a greater impact on memory-dependent functional status than support groups. Yoga was associated with better functional status and improved caregiver burden relative to wellness education. CCT had the greatest impact on cognition compared to yoga. Taken together, comparisons of groups of program components suggest that knowledge-based interventions like wellness education benefit patient well-being (e.g., QoL and mood). Skill-based interventions like yoga and memory compensation training aid the maintenance of functional status. Notably, better adherence produced better outcomes. Future personalized intervention approaches for pwMCI may include different combinations of behavioral strategies selected to optimize outcomes prioritized by patient values and preferences.
行为干预措施减轻基于退化的认知衰退影响的效果尚不清楚。为了更好地解决这一差距,我们总结了针对轻度认知障碍(pwMCI)患者及其伴侣的健康行动促进独立和思维(HABIT®)计划的研究。HABIT®包括记忆补偿训练、计算机认知训练(CCT)、瑜伽、患者和伴侣支持小组以及健康教育培训。引用的研究包括:(i)对临床项目完成者进行调查,以确定结果的优先事项;(ii)一项五臂、多地点集群随机、比较效果试验;(iii)和一项三臂辅助研究。pwMCI 的生活质量(QoL)被认为是一个高优先级的结果。在所有数据集,研究结果表明,在包括健康教育培训且排除 CCT 的组中,生活质量受到的影响最大。与 CCT 相比,健康教育培训对情绪的影响更大。瑜伽对依赖记忆的功能状态的影响大于支持小组。与健康教育培训相比,瑜伽与更好的功能状态和改善的照顾者负担相关。与瑜伽相比,CCT 对认知的影响最大。总的来说,对项目组成部分的组进行比较表明,像健康教育培训这样基于知识的干预措施有益于患者的幸福感(例如,QoL 和情绪)。像瑜伽和记忆补偿训练这样的技能干预措施有助于维持功能状态。值得注意的是,更好的依从性会产生更好的结果。未来针对 pwMCI 的个性化干预方法可能包括选择不同的行为策略组合,以优化患者价值观和偏好优先考虑的结果。