Washington State University, Pullman, WA, United States of America.
University of Idaho, Moscow, ID, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2022 Apr 13;17(4):e0266026. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0266026. eCollection 2022.
Age and gender differences are prominent in the temperament literature, with the former particularly salient in infancy and the latter noted as early as the first year of life. This study represents a meta-analysis utilizing Infant Behavior Questionnaire-Revised (IBQ-R) data collected across multiple laboratories (N = 4438) to overcome limitations of smaller samples in elucidating links among temperament, age, and gender in early childhood. Algorithmic modeling techniques were leveraged to discern the extent to which the 14 IBQ-R subscale scores accurately classified participating children as boys (n = 2,298) and girls (n = 2,093), and into three age groups: youngest (< 24 weeks; n = 1,102), mid-range (24 to 48 weeks; n = 2,557), and oldest (> 48 weeks; n = 779). Additionally, simultaneous classification into age and gender categories was performed, providing an opportunity to consider the extent to which gender differences in temperament are informed by infant age. Results indicated that overall age group classification was more accurate than child gender models, suggesting that age-related changes are more salient than gender differences in early childhood with respect to temperament attributes. However, gender-based classification was superior in the oldest age group, suggesting temperament differences between boys and girls are accentuated with development. Fear emerged as the subscale contributing to accurate classifications most notably overall. This study leads infancy research and meta-analytic investigations more broadly in a new direction as a methodological demonstration, and also provides most optimal comparative data for the IBQ-R based on the largest and most representative dataset to date.
年龄和性别差异在气质文献中表现突出,前者在婴儿期尤为明显,后者早在生命的第一年就被注意到。本研究利用婴儿行为问卷修订版(IBQ-R)在多个实验室收集的数据进行元分析(N=4438),以克服较小样本阐明幼儿期气质、年龄和性别之间联系的局限性。算法建模技术被用来辨别 14 个 IBQ-R 分量得分在多大程度上准确地将参与的儿童分类为男孩(n=2298)和女孩(n=2093),并分为三个年龄组:最小(<24 周;n=1102)、中等范围(24 至 48 周;n=2557)和最大(>48 周;n=779)。此外,还同时进行了年龄和性别类别的分类,为考虑气质性别差异受婴儿年龄影响的程度提供了机会。结果表明,总体年龄组分类比儿童性别模型更准确,这表明与年龄相关的变化在幼儿期的气质特征方面比性别差异更为突出。然而,在最大年龄组中,基于性别的分类更为优越,这表明男孩和女孩之间的气质差异随着发育而加剧。恐惧作为分量表,总体上对准确分类的贡献最大。本研究为婴儿研究和更广泛的元分析提供了新的方法学示范,并为 IBQ-R 提供了迄今为止最大和最具代表性的数据集的最佳比较数据。