Amporfu Eugenia, Apanya Selom, Amoako Prince
Department of Economics, Kwame Nkrumah University of Science and Technology, Kumasi, Ghana.
Health Serv Insights. 2022 Apr 11;15:11786329221088693. doi: 10.1177/11786329221088693. eCollection 2022.
The Ghana National Health Insurance Scheme (NHIS) seeks to provide access to quality healthcare to its members regardless of the health facility in which they receive care. However, it is unclear if all members of the Scheme receive quality care. The objective of the study is to examine the equity of perceived healthcare quality received by NHIS members depending on the type of facility in which care was provided. The study purposively sampled 2000 NHIS members who sought malaria treatment in the study areas. Only patients who had visited the health facilities at least twice not more than 12 months, before the data collection, were sampled. The SERVQUAL model was used to examine perceived quality of healthcare services in 5 quality dimensions: Reliability, Assurance, Tangibility, Empathy, and Responsiveness. These quality dimensions were compared in health facilities according to ownership (public, private, and faith-based facilities), capacity (hospital vs health centers), and finally location (urban vs rural health facilities). Instrumental variable estimation method was used to analyze data to address health facility selection bias problem. The results showed that faith-based health facilities scored the highest in all 5 perceived quality dimensions followed by public and private. Hospitals had higher score in perceived quality than health centers just as urban facilities scored higher in quality than rural facilities. These results represent high inequality in the perceived quality of care received by NHIS members.
加纳国家医疗保险计划(NHIS)旨在为其成员提供获得优质医疗服务的机会,无论他们在哪个医疗机构接受治疗。然而,尚不清楚该计划的所有成员是否都能获得优质护理。本研究的目的是根据提供护理的机构类型,调查NHIS成员所感受到的医疗质量的公平性。该研究有目的地抽取了2000名在研究地区寻求疟疾治疗的NHIS成员。仅对在数据收集前至少12个月内去过医疗机构两次且不超过两次的患者进行抽样。SERVQUAL模型用于在五个质量维度上考察医疗服务的感知质量:可靠性、保证性、有形性、同理心和响应性。这些质量维度在不同所有制(公立、私立和宗教性质的机构)、规模(医院与健康中心)以及最终地理位置(城市与农村医疗机构)的医疗机构中进行了比较。使用工具变量估计方法分析数据,以解决医疗机构选择偏差问题。结果显示,宗教性质的医疗机构在所有五个感知质量维度上得分最高,其次是公立和私立机构。医院在感知质量方面的得分高于健康中心,正如城市医疗机构在质量方面的得分高于农村医疗机构一样。这些结果表明,NHIS成员所感受到的护理质量存在高度不平等。