Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 77 Massachusetts Ave, Cambridge, MA, 02139, USA.
Northern Arizona University, 1900 S Knoles Dr, Flagstaff, AZ, 86011, USA.
Appl Ergon. 2022 Sep;103:103768. doi: 10.1016/j.apergo.2022.103768. Epub 2022 Apr 20.
Wearable robotic systems, such as exoskeletons, are designed to assist human motion; however, they are typically only studied during level walking. Before exoskeletons are broadly integrated into unstructured environments, it will be important to evaluate exoskeletons in a broader set of relevant tasks. A balance beam traverse was used to represent a constrained foot placement task for examining balance and stability. Participants (n = 17) completed the task in their own shoes (Pre-Exoskeleton and Post-Exoskeleton trials), and when wearing a lower-limb exoskeleton (Dephy ExoBoot) in both powered and unpowered states. Data were collected via inertial measurement units (on the torso and feet) and analyzed on a pooled level (with data from all participants) and on an individual level (participant-specific confidence intervals). When examining pooled data, it was observed that the exoskeleton had mixed effects on stride stability metrics. When compared to the Post-Exoskeleton shoe control, it was observed that stride duration was increased when wearing the exoskeleton (both powered and unpowered states), while normalized stride length and stride speed were not affected. Despite the changes in stride stability, overall balance (as measured by torso sway) remained unaffected by exoskeleton state. On an individual level, it was observed that not all participants followed these general trends, and within each metric, some increased, some decreased, and some had no change in the Powered Exoskeleton condition when compared to the Post-Exoskeleton Shoe condition: normalized stride length (0% increased, 12% decreased, 88% no change), stride duration (35% increased, 0% decreased, 65% no change), and torso sway (0% increased, 12% decreased, 88% no change). Our findings suggest that the lower-limb exoskeleton evaluated can be used during tasks that require balancing, and we recommend that balancing tasks be included in standards for exoskeleton evaluation.
可穿戴机器人系统,如外骨骼,旨在辅助人类运动;然而,它们通常仅在水平行走期间进行研究。在将外骨骼广泛集成到非结构化环境之前,评估外骨骼在更广泛的相关任务中表现非常重要。平衡木穿越被用来代表一个受限的足部放置任务,以检查平衡和稳定性。参与者(n=17)在穿着自己的鞋子(预外骨骼和后外骨骼试验)和穿着下肢外骨骼(Dephy ExoBoot)的动力和无动力状态下完成了任务。数据通过惯性测量单元(在躯干和脚部)收集,并在汇总水平(所有参与者的数据)和个体水平(参与者特定的置信区间)上进行分析。在检查汇总数据时,观察到外骨骼对步幅稳定性指标有混合影响。与后外骨骼鞋控制相比,观察到穿着外骨骼时步幅持续时间增加(动力和无动力状态),而标准化步幅长度和步幅速度不受影响。尽管步幅稳定性发生变化,但躯干摆动(作为平衡的衡量标准)总体上不受外骨骼状态的影响。在个体水平上,观察到并非所有参与者都遵循这些总体趋势,并且在每个指标中,一些参与者增加,一些参与者减少,而在动力外骨骼条件下与后外骨骼鞋条件相比,一些参与者没有变化:标准化步幅长度(增加 0%,减少 12%,无变化 88%)、步幅持续时间(增加 35%,减少 0%,无变化 65%)和躯干摆动(增加 0%,减少 12%,无变化 88%)。我们的研究结果表明,评估的下肢外骨骼可在需要平衡的任务中使用,我们建议在评估外骨骼的标准中包括平衡任务。