Wang Shuo-Lin, Li Wei, Li Tian-Fang, Liang Xu, Yan Ye-Lan, Liu Sheng-Yun
Department of Rheumatology, First Affiliated Hospital of Zhengzhou University Zhengzhou, Henan, China.
Am J Transl Res. 2022 May 15;14(5):3247-3260. eCollection 2022.
Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is a multisystem inflammatory disease of unknown etiology. Corticosteroids and immunosuppressive agents are the principal forms of treatment for this condition. While cardiovascular disease (CVD) is known to be a major cause of death in patients with SLE, there has been no improvement over the last few decades with regard to diagnosis, treatment, or prognosis. The QRISK3 algorithm is a new algorithm that includes SLE-related risk factors; this tool can predict the risk of CVD over a ten-year period. In this study, involving 180 patients, we compared the performance of the Framingham risk score, the recalibrated risk prediction SCORE, and QRISK3 for the assessment of CVD in patients with a long course of disease and low disease activity. Then, we used a more efficient algorithm, QRISK3 to identify the risk factors for CVD. This was a prospective and cross-sectional study involving 116 patients. All patients fulfilled the ACR criteria. The systemic lupus erythematosus disease activity index 2000 (SLEDAI-2K) is widely used to assess disease activity in SLE patients; patients with a SLEDAI-2K less than or equal to 4 are considered to be stable. Thus, we defined well-controlled patients as those with a SLEDAI-2K score less than or equal to 4. The dose of glucocorticoid (GC) that patients received was less or equal to 10 mg per day. We recorded and assessed a range of traditional risk factors, current treatments, comorbidities, data at the time of onset, and SLE-related evaluations. The QRISK3 score, and the relative risk (RR) that this score defined, were used to estimate the risk of CVD in patients with SLE. According to these relative risks, the patients were divided into low- (n=28), intermediate- (n=46), and high-relative risk (n=31) groups for subgroup analysis. Of the 116 patients enrolled, 105 were eligible to be assessed for the risk of CVD. By univariate analyses, the RR was significantly related with age at the time of enrolment (<0.001), age at onset (<0.001), resting heart rate (RHR) (<0.001), present dose of GCs (<0.001), present SLEDAI-2K (=0.015), aerobic exercise (<0.001), initial SLEDAI-2K (<0.001), and initial dose of GCs (=0.048). In the multiple linear regression model, the RR of CVD was significantly correlated with the initial SLEDAI-2K score (β=2.112, <0.001), initial dose of GCs (β=-0.009, =0.041), resting heart rate (β=0.241, =0.003) and age at onset (β=-0.208, =0.004). Pearson's correlation showed that RHR was significantly associated with aerobic exercise (r=-0.322, p=0.001). Subgroup analysis further identified a positive correlation between the history of nephritis, metabolic syndrome (MetS), aerobic exercise, present dose of GCs, and the RR of CVD. Patients with long-term but well-controlled SLE had a high relative risk of CVD and that this was associated with resting heart rate (P=0.003), history of lupus nephritis (P<0.001), initial SLEDAI-2K score (P<0.001), and metabolic syndrome (P=0.017). However, age at onset (P<0.001), use of hydroxychloroquine (P=0.30) and Mycophenolate mofetil (P=0.01), and the initial dose of glucocorticoid (P=0.049), were protective factors. Younger SLE patients had a significantly higher relative risk of CVD than older patients (p<0.001). QRISK3 detected more SLE patients at high risk of CVD when compared to the Framingham and recalibrate SCORE. To reduce the risk of CVD in SLE patients, measures should be taken both during the initial stages of disease and for long-term management.
系统性红斑狼疮(SLE)是一种病因不明的多系统炎症性疾病。皮质类固醇和免疫抑制剂是该病症的主要治疗方式。虽然已知心血管疾病(CVD)是SLE患者的主要死因,但在过去几十年里,在诊断、治疗或预后方面并无改善。QRISK3算法是一种新算法,纳入了与SLE相关的风险因素;该工具可预测十年内患CVD的风险。在这项涉及180名患者的研究中,我们比较了弗雷明汉风险评分、重新校准的风险预测SCORE以及QRISK3在评估病程长且疾病活动度低的患者发生CVD方面的表现。然后,我们使用更有效的算法QRISK3来识别CVD的风险因素。这是一项涉及116名患者的前瞻性横断面研究。所有患者均符合美国风湿病学会(ACR)标准。系统性红斑狼疮疾病活动指数2000(SLEDAI - 2K)被广泛用于评估SLE患者的疾病活动度;SLEDAI - 2K小于或等于4的患者被认为病情稳定。因此,我们将病情控制良好的患者定义为SLEDAI - 2K评分小于或等于4的患者。患者接受的糖皮质激素(GC)剂量小于或等于每日10毫克。我们记录并评估了一系列传统风险因素、当前治疗方法、合并症、发病时的数据以及与SLE相关的评估指标。QRISK3评分以及该评分所定义的相对风险(RR)用于估计SLE患者发生CVD的风险。根据这些相对风险,将患者分为低风险组(n = 28)、中风险组(n = 46)和高相对风险组(n = 31)进行亚组分析。在纳入的116名患者中,105名符合评估CVD风险的条件。通过单因素分析,RR与入组时年龄(<0.001)、发病年龄(<0.001)、静息心率(RHR)(<0.001)、当前GC剂量(<0.001)、当前SLEDAI - 2K(=0.015)、有氧运动(<0.001)、初始SLEDAI - 2K(<0.001)以及初始GC剂量(=0.048)显著相关。在多元线性回归模型中,CVD的RR与初始SLEDAI - 2K评分(β = 2.112,<0.001)、初始GC剂量(β = -0.009,=0.041)、静息心率(β = 0.241,=0.003)和发病年龄(β = -0.208,=0.004)显著相关。Pearson相关性分析表明,RHR与有氧运动显著相关(r = -0.322,p = 0.001)。亚组分析进一步确定,肾炎病史、代谢综合征(MetS)、有氧运动、当前GC剂量与CVD的RR之间存在正相关。长期病情控制良好的SLE患者发生CVD的相对风险较高,这与静息心率(P = 0.003)、狼疮肾炎病史(P < 0.001)、初始SLEDAI - 2K评分(P < 0.001)以及代谢综合征(P = 0.017)相关。然而,发病年龄(P < 0.001)、使用羟氯喹(P = 0.30)和霉酚酸酯(P = 0.01)以及初始糖皮质激素剂量(P = 0.049)是保护因素。年轻的SLE患者发生CVD的相对风险显著高于老年患者(p < 0.001)。与弗雷明汉和重新校准的SCORE相比,QRISK3检测出更多处于CVD高风险的SLE患者。为降低SLE患者发生CVD的风险,应在疾病初始阶段和长期管理中都采取措施。