Bowker L H, Maurer L
Women Health. 1987;12(1):25-45. doi: 10.1300/J013v12n01_03.
Knowledge gained from a literature summary was tested against data obtained from a national volunteer sample of 1,000 battered women recruited primarily through solicitation by an advertisement in Woman's Day magazine. In comparison with other help-sources (social service agencies, the clergy, the police, lawyers, women's groups, shelters), medical personnel were found to have been used fairly frequently, but they were seen by the battered women as less effective than any other group. Quotes taken from indepth interviewers with 146 of the battered wives are used to bring life to the comparative statistics. Specific reasons for the low effectiveness ratings of the medical profession are considered, and ways to improve service delivery ratings are discussed.
从文献综述中获得的知识,通过对从全国范围内主要通过《妇女日》杂志上的一则广告招募的1000名受虐妇女志愿者样本中获取的数据进行了检验。与其他帮助来源(社会服务机构、神职人员、警察、律师、妇女团体、庇护所)相比,发现医疗人员被使用的频率相当高,但受虐妇女认为他们比其他任何群体的效果都要差。从对146名受虐妻子的深入访谈中摘录的引语,为这些比较统计数据增添了生动性。文中考虑了医疗行业有效性评级较低的具体原因,并讨论了提高服务提供评级的方法。