McKinley Catherine, Knipp Hannah, Lilly Jenn
Tulane University School of Social Work, New Orleans, Louisiana, USA.
City, Community, and Culture PhD Program, Tulane University, New Orleans, Louisiana, USA.
Child Fam Soc Work. 2022 May;27(2):185-194. doi: 10.1111/cfs.12868. Epub 2021 Aug 2.
Research indicates that effective disciplinary practices, such as offering praise and teaching acceptable versus non-acceptable behaviour, can act as protective factors against the social and behavioural health disparities experienced by Native Americans (NA). The purpose of this critical ethnographic study ( = 436 qualitative elder, adult, youth and professional participants) was to use the Framework of Historical Oppression, Resilience, and Transcendence (FHORT) to qualitatively examine participants' reported experiences of disciplinary practices. Thematic analysis of qualitative results indicated several approaches to disciplining children, which included the following themes: (a) Establishing Structure and Boundaries; (b) Taking Away Privileges and Rewarding Good Behavior; and (c) Teaching Right from Wrong. Results indicate that despite experiencing historical oppression, NAs still report many disciplinary and other parenting practices contributing to family resilience that were present prior to colonization. Communal and relational supports contribute to positive parenting practices, indicating an importance to promote holistic and inclusive clinical treatment approaches.
研究表明,有效的纪律措施,如给予表扬以及教导可接受与不可接受的行为,可作为保护因素,防止美国原住民(NA)所经历的社会和行为健康差异。这项关键的人种志研究(436名定性研究参与者,包括长者、成年人、青年和专业人士)的目的是使用历史压迫、复原力和超越框架(FHORT)对参与者报告的纪律措施经历进行定性研究。对定性结果的主题分析表明了几种管教孩子的方法,包括以下主题:(a)建立结构和边界;(b)剥夺特权和奖励良好行为;(c)明辨是非。结果表明,尽管经历了历史压迫,但美国原住民仍报告了许多在殖民之前就存在的有助于家庭复原力的纪律措施和其他育儿做法。社区和关系支持有助于积极的育儿做法,这表明促进整体和包容性临床治疗方法的重要性。