Goldstick Jason E, Jay Jonathan
Injury Prevention Center, University of Michigan, 2800 Plymouth Road, Suite B10-G080, Ann Arbor, MI 48109-2800 USA.
Department of Emergency Medicine, University of Michigan, 1500 E Medical Center Drive, Ann Arbor, MI 48109 USA.
Curr Epidemiol Rep. 2022;9(3):135-141. doi: 10.1007/s40471-022-00292-x. Epub 2022 Jul 8.
Community violence is a serious public health problem, and generational investments are being made to address it. Agent-based models (ABMs) are computational tools that can help to optimize allocation of those investments, analogous to how computer simulation models, broadly, have informed decision making in other fields, such as infectious disease control. In this review, we describe ABMs, explain their potential role in community violence research, discuss recent studies that have applied ABMs to community violence, and point to opportunities for further progress.
We identified three recent studies that applied ABMs to community violence research, which points to the paucity of this line of work. Each of these works leverages a major advantage of ABMs-their ability to study the natural evolution of a process governed by the actions of autonomous agents, and how that evolution changes under counterfactual conditions, such as different intervention strategies (e.g., violence interruption), and policy changes (e.g., alcohol outlet licensing policies).
ABMs continue to be an underutilized tool for the study of community violence. Their increased use could add important information to help stakeholders decide between competing intervention strategies in terms of their costs and the overall resulting changes in violence rates. In addition, ABMs have value in identifying unintended changes/diffusions resulting from interventions. Regardless of the application, ABMs can only be impactful if stakeholders believe and use the information, pointing to the importance of engaging policy makers and other stakeholders in the model formulation process when possible.
社区暴力是一个严重的公共卫生问题,目前正在进行代际投资以解决这一问题。基于主体的模型(ABM)是一种计算工具,可有助于优化这些投资的分配,类似于计算机模拟模型在传染病控制等其他领域为决策提供信息的方式。在本综述中,我们描述了ABM,解释了它们在社区暴力研究中的潜在作用,讨论了最近将ABM应用于社区暴力的研究,并指出了进一步取得进展的机会。
我们确定了三项最近将ABM应用于社区暴力研究的研究,这表明这方面的工作较少。这些研究均利用了ABM的一个主要优势——它们能够研究由自主主体的行动所支配的过程的自然演变,以及这种演变在反事实条件下如何变化,例如不同的干预策略(如暴力中断)和政策变化(如酒精销售点许可政策)。
ABM仍然是研究社区暴力未得到充分利用的工具。更多地使用它们可以提供重要信息,帮助利益相关者在相互竞争的干预策略之间,根据成本和暴力率的总体变化来做出决策。此外,ABM在识别干预导致的意外变化/扩散方面具有价值。无论应用如何,只有当利益相关者相信并使用这些信息时,ABM才会产生影响,这表明在可能的情况下,让政策制定者和其他利益相关者参与模型制定过程非常重要。