Department of Nursing, Max Stern Yezreel Valley College, Emek Yezreel, Israel.
Galilee Medical Center, Nahariya, Israel.
J Clin Nurs. 2023 Jul;32(13-14):3644-3655. doi: 10.1111/jocn.16449. Epub 2022 Jul 19.
To evaluate the relationship between nurse-patient-initiated participation, nurses' attitudes towards patient's participation, and patients' adherence to treatment. Specifically, to (1) explore nurse-patient participation during haemodialysis and quantify the information into measurable indices; (2) determine the haemodialysis patient's adherence to treatment; (3) describe nurses' attitudes towards patient participation; and (4) establish the relationships between nurse-patient-initiated participation, nurses' attitudes towards patient participation and patients' adherence to treatment.
To improve haemodialysis patients' health, it is crucial to identify nurses' and patients' factors facilitating adherence to treatment.
An exploratory-sequential mixed-methods (quantitative and qualitative) design.
All nurses working at a dialysis ward (n = 30) and their randomly selected patients (n = 102) participated. Qualitative data on nurse-patient-initiated participation were derived from transcribed nurse-patient conversations and quantified for further analyses. Nurses' attitudes towards patient participation were collected via questionnaire, and adherence to treatment via observed reduction in prescribed haemodialysis time. [CONSORT-SPI guidelines].
Content analysis of the conversations indicated that nurse-initiated participation focused on patient's medical condition, treatment plan and education; while patients initiated more small talk. Non-adherence to treatment was significant (Mean = 0.19 h; SD = 0.33). Regression analyses indicated that nurses' attitude towards participation was negatively linked to patient adherence, while patient-nurse-initiated participation was unrelated. Nurses' attitudes towards patient participation moderated the relationship between nurse-patient-initiated participation and patient adherence: the more positive the attitude towards inclusion the more negative the link between patient or nurse-initiated participation and patient adherence.
The findings provided paradoxical insights: Nurses' positive attitudes towards participation lead them to accept the patient's position for shortening haemodialysis treatment, so that adherence to care decreases.
Nurses require education on negotiating methods to help achieve patient adherence while respecting the patient's opinion. Patients should be educated how to approach nurses, seeking the information they need.
评估护士发起的参与、护士对患者参与的态度以及患者对治疗的依从性之间的关系。具体而言,(1)探索血液透析过程中的护患参与,并将信息量化为可衡量的指标;(2)确定血液透析患者对治疗的依从性;(3)描述护士对患者参与的态度;(4)确定护士发起的参与、护士对患者参与的态度与患者对治疗的依从性之间的关系。
为了改善血液透析患者的健康状况,确定促进治疗依从性的护士和患者因素至关重要。
探索性序贯混合方法(定量和定性)设计。
所有在透析病房工作的护士(n=30)及其随机选择的患者(n=102)均参与了研究。护士-患者发起的参与的定性数据来自转录的护士-患者对话,并进行了量化分析。护士对患者参与的态度通过问卷收集,治疗依从性通过观察到的减少规定的血液透析时间来收集。[CONSORT-SPI 指南]。
对话的内容分析表明,护士发起的参与侧重于患者的病情、治疗计划和教育;而患者发起的更多是闲聊。治疗不依从的情况很明显(平均值=0.19 小时;标准差=0.33)。回归分析表明,护士对参与的态度与患者的依从性呈负相关,而患者-护士发起的参与与患者的依从性无关。护士对患者参与的态度调节了护士-患者发起的参与与患者依从性之间的关系:对包容性的态度越积极,患者或护士发起的参与与患者依从性之间的联系就越负面。
研究结果提供了矛盾的见解:护士对参与的积极态度导致他们接受患者缩短血液透析治疗的立场,从而降低了对治疗的依从性。
护士需要接受有关协商方法的教育,以帮助患者保持治疗依从性,同时尊重患者的意见。应教育患者如何与护士接触,寻求他们所需的信息。