Shamaeian Razavi Nazanin, Jalili Mohammad, Sandars John, Gandomkar Roghayeh
Department of Medical Education, School of Medicine, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
Health Professions Education Research Center, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
Med J Islam Repub Iran. 2022 Feb 14;36:8. doi: 10.47176/mjiri.36.8. eCollection 2022.
Effective leadership is critical for the performance of health care teams and their intended outcomes for patient care. Given that team leadership is a modifiable and teachable skill, there is a need for a better understanding of this multidimensional behavior to inform future leadership training for health care action (HCA) teams. This systematized review identifies reported observed leadership behaviors in HCA teams, defined as interdisciplinary teams which complete vital tasks in complex, time-pressured, and dynamic situations. We searched CINAHL, MEDLINE, Scopus, PsycINFO, and Web of Science for peer-reviewed, English language articles using single and combinations of keywords including leadership, health care action team, and teamwork, individually. We included articles published until June 2021 without any specific beginning date. From 242 records, 13 articles were included in the review. We categorized our findings of team leadership behaviors in HCAs based on an existing framework of three dimensions: transition processes, action processes, and interpersonal skills. The most-reported behaviors for transition processes were encouraging team members' input, (re)assessing the team's situation, and confirming team members' understandings. The action processes dimension consisted of behaviors that included monitoring the progress of the patient, managing resources, asking for help when needed, coaching/supervising, and assisting team members as needed. Finally, closed-loop communication and facilitating team members speaking up behaviors were categorized as interpersonal skills. Although team leadership has been an area of focus in the field of health professions education, little attention has been paid to identifying the observable behaviors of effective team leaders in an HCA team. The study identified several new essential team leadership behaviors that had not been previously described, including seeking feedback, shared decision making, and aspects of interpersonal communication. The findings can inform educators in planning and implementing strategies to enhance HCA team leadership training, with the ultimate potential to improve health care.
有效的领导力对于医疗团队的绩效及其预期的患者护理结果至关重要。鉴于团队领导力是一种可改变且可传授的技能,有必要更好地理解这种多维度行为,以为未来医疗行动(HCA)团队的领导力培训提供参考。本系统综述确定了HCA团队中已报道的观察到的领导行为,HCA团队被定义为在复杂、时间紧迫和动态情况下完成重要任务的跨学科团队。我们在CINAHL、MEDLINE、Scopus、PsycINFO和Web of Science中搜索了同行评审的英文文章,分别使用包括领导力、医疗行动团队和团队合作等关键词的单一词汇及组合词汇。我们纳入了截至2021年6月发表的文章,没有设定任何具体的起始日期。从242条记录中,13篇文章被纳入综述。我们基于一个由过渡过程、行动过程和人际技能三个维度组成的现有框架,对HCA中团队领导行为的研究结果进行了分类。过渡过程中报道最多的行为是鼓励团队成员发表意见、(重新)评估团队状况以及确认团队成员的理解。行动过程维度包括监测患者进展、管理资源、在需要时寻求帮助、指导/监督以及根据需要协助团队成员等行为。最后,闭环沟通和促进团队成员畅所欲言的行为被归类为人际技能。尽管团队领导力一直是健康职业教育领域的一个重点关注领域,但在识别HCA团队中有效团队领导者的可观察行为方面却很少受到关注。该研究确定了一些此前未被描述过的新的重要团队领导行为,包括寻求反馈、共享决策以及人际沟通的各个方面。这些发现可为教育工作者规划和实施增强HCA团队领导力培训的策略提供参考,最终有可能改善医疗保健。