Horton Cal
University of Goldsmiths, London, UK.
Br J Educ Psychol. 2023 Mar;93(1):73-90. doi: 10.1111/bjep.12540. Epub 2022 Sep 9.
Transgender children are known to face a wide range of barriers, difficulties and injustices at school. Few studies have focused on the educational experiences of trans pupils who socially transition at or before primary school, with no such studies in the UK.
To learn about the at-school experiences of transgender children who socially transitioned at or before primary school in the UK, listening to children's and parental accounts of navigating cisnormativity in UK primary and early secondary education.
The primary sample included 30 parents whose children had socially transitioned under the age of 11 in the UK. This sample was complemented with data directly from 10 of these trans children. The primary sample was accessed through six trans positive parenting groups in the UK, supplemented through snowball sampling.
Semi-structured interviews produced a rich and detailed qualitative data set, that was analysed through inductive thematic analysis.
Three major themes are presented, highlighting experiences of (i) institutional cisnormativity in UK schools, (ii) a failure to protect trans children and (iii) evidence of educational injustice. The results demonstrate how institutional cisnormativity leaves trans pupils in unsafe educational environments, contributing to school drop-out and trauma.
Cisnormative attitudes normalize injustice, making it acceptable for trans children to lose access to education, or to experience trauma in school. Educators, schools and school leaders need to take action to protect trans children in our schools.
众所周知,跨性别儿童在学校面临着各种各样的障碍、困难和不公正待遇。很少有研究关注在小学或小学之前进行社会性别转换的跨性别学生的教育经历,英国尚无此类研究。
了解在英国小学或小学之前进行社会性别转换的跨性别儿童的在校经历,倾听儿童及其父母讲述在英国小学和初中早期应对顺性别规范的情况。
主要样本包括30名家长,他们的孩子在英国11岁之前进行了社会性别转换。该样本还补充了其中10名跨性别儿童的直接数据。主要样本通过英国的六个支持跨性别的家长团体获取,并通过滚雪球抽样进行补充。
半结构化访谈产生了丰富而详细的定性数据集,并通过归纳主题分析进行了分析。
呈现了三个主要主题,突出了(i)英国学校的制度性顺性别规范、(ii)未能保护跨性别儿童以及(iii)教育不公正的证据。结果表明,制度性顺性别规范如何使跨性别学生处于不安全的教育环境中,导致辍学和创伤。
顺性别规范的态度使不公正正常化,使得跨性别儿童失去受教育机会或在学校遭受创伤变得可以接受。教育工作者、学校和学校领导需要采取行动保护我们学校中的跨性别儿童。