LeAnn Brown, Claire Pillot-Loiseau
Laboratoire Parole et Langage (LPL) UMR 7309/CNRS, Aix-Marseille Université / CLESTHIA EA 7345, Sorbonne-Nouvelle Université, Paris, France.
Sorbonne-Nouvelle Université and Laboratoire de Phonétique et Phonologie (LPP) UMR 7018/CNRS, Paris, France.
J Voice. 2025 Jan;39(1):282.e1-282.e17. doi: 10.1016/j.jvoice.2022.08.001. Epub 2022 Oct 6.
A quantitative comparative research design.
Phonetic and statistical analyses of continuous speech samples produced by AFAB non-binary and cisgender participants. Vocal cues were mean fundamental frequency (F0) and bright voice quality, measured by cepstral peak prominence-smoothed and spectral slope, with speaker gender as the predictor.
At the group level, non-binary participants produced intermediate F0 values - significantly lower than the cis women's and significantly higher than the cis men's. Individually, the majority of non-binary participants produced mean F0 in this intermediate range. Non-binary participants produced significantly less negative spectral slope and higher cepstral peak prominence-smoothed, indicative of a brighter, more resonant voice quality. Individual-level results indicated that vocal training and vocal tract physiology did not fully account for the results found.
Participants' agency, particularly their motivation to alter vocal output to avoid being misgendered, has an effect on the AFAB non-binary participants' F0 production and potentially their voice quality. The majority of AFAB non-binary participants uniquely produced the cue combination of intermediate F0 and bright voice quality.
1)调查出生时被指定为女性(AFAB)的非二元性别者产生的嗓音变化是否与顺性别(cis)参与者产生的嗓音变化不同。预计非二元性别参与者产生的线索值将与顺性别参与者产生的值不同。2)确定先前对AFAB非二元性别参与者明亮嗓音质量的主观评估是否可量化,如果可以,非二元性别和顺性别参与者在嗓音质量产生方面是否存在差异。
定量比较研究设计。
对AFAB非二元性别和顺性别参与者产生的连续语音样本进行语音和统计分析。嗓音线索为平均基频(F0)和明亮嗓音质量,通过谐波峰值突出度平滑和频谱斜率测量,以说话者性别作为预测变量。
在组水平上,非二元性别参与者产生的F0值处于中间范围——显著低于顺性别女性,且显著高于顺性别男性。个体层面上,大多数非二元性别参与者产生的平均F0值在这个中间范围内。非二元性别参与者产生的负频谱斜率显著更小,谐波峰值突出度平滑更高,表明嗓音质量更明亮、更有共鸣。个体水平结果表明,嗓音训练和声道生理学不能完全解释所发现的结果。
参与者的能动性,特别是他们改变嗓音输出以避免被错误性别认定的动机,对AFAB非二元性别参与者的F0产生有影响,可能也对他们的嗓音质量有影响。大多数AFAB非二元性别参与者独特地产生了中间F0和明亮嗓音质量的线索组合。