Department of Health Economics, Center for Public Health, Medical University of Vienna, Kinderspitalgasse 15, 1090 Wien, Austria.
Department of Psychiatry, University of Oxford, Warneford Hospital, Oxford OX3 7JX, UK.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2022 Sep 22;19(19):11985. doi: 10.3390/ijerph191911985.
The Positive Memory Training (PoMeT) trial demonstrated reduced depression symptoms at 3 months for schizophrenia, but its longer-term outcome and cost impacts remain unknown. This study is a within-trial cost-utility analysis with quality-adjusted life years (QALYs) as outcome based on health-related quality of life (HRQoL) measurement and secondary outcome analyses of capability well-being. The incremental cost-effectiveness of PoMeT was compared to Treatment As Usual only (TAU) over 9 months from the 'health and social' care and 'societal' perspectives. Uncertainty was explored using bootstrapping and sensitivity analyses for cost outliers and outcome methods. HRQoL improvement was observed for both PoMeT and TAU at 3 months, but reached statistical significance and was sustained only for TAU. There was no change in capability well-being and no significant group difference in QALYs gained over 9 months. Mean intervention cost was GBP 823. Compared to TAU, PoMeT had significantly higher mental health care costs (+GBP 1251, 95% CI GBP 185 to GBP 2316) during the trial, but 'health and social care' and 'societal' cost differences were non-significant. Compared to the before-trial period, psychiatric medication costs increased significantly in both groups. The probability of PoMeT being cost-effective in the given format over 9 months was <30% and decreased further in sensitivity analyses.. Generalizability remains limited since the before-after cost analysis revealed additional treatment effects also in the TAU group that likely diminished the incremental impacts and cost-effectiveness of PoMeT. It is not clear whether an active post-intervention follow-up could result in sustained longer-term effects and improved cost-effectiveness.
积极记忆训练(PoMeT)试验表明,精神分裂症患者在 3 个月时抑郁症状减轻,但长期结果和成本影响仍不清楚。本研究是一项基于健康相关生活质量(HRQoL)测量和能力幸福感二次结果分析的试验内成本效用分析,以调整后的生命年(QALYs)作为结果。从“健康和社会”护理和“社会”角度来看,PoMeT 的增量成本效益与仅接受常规治疗(TAU)在 9 个月内进行了比较。通过成本异常值和结果方法的自举和敏感性分析来探索不确定性。在 3 个月时,PoMeT 和 TAU 均观察到 HRQoL 改善,但仅 TAU 达到统计学意义并持续存在。能力幸福感没有变化,9 个月内获得的 QALYs 也没有显著的组间差异。干预措施的平均成本为 823 英镑。与 TAU 相比,PoMeT 在试验期间的心理健康护理费用显著更高(+1251 英镑,95%CI 185 英镑至 2316 英镑),但“健康和社会护理”和“社会”成本差异无统计学意义。与试验前相比,两组的精神药物治疗费用均显著增加。PoMeT 在 9 个月内具有成本效益的概率<30%,并且在敏感性分析中进一步降低。由于前后成本分析显示 TAU 组也存在额外的治疗效果,这可能降低了 PoMeT 的增量影响和成本效益,因此推广性仍然有限。目前尚不清楚积极的干预后随访是否会产生持续的长期效果和提高成本效益。