Department of Sociology, University of Toronto - Mississauga, Ontario, Canada.
Department of Sociology and Criminology, University of Windsor, Ontario, Canada.
Can Rev Sociol. 2022 Nov;59(4):470-489. doi: 10.1111/cars.12407. Epub 2022 Oct 27.
The criminalization of Black people in Canada, and their relative distrust of systems of criminal justice, are well-established realities. Here, we problematize the monolithic construction of Blackness implied in this statement. Interrogating differences in African-born immigrants' responses on the General Social Survey, we build on existing theories regarding the 1.5 generation of immigrants in order to demonstrate that those Black immigrants who arrived as children, grew up in Canada, and participated in Canadian education, labour markets, and other institutions of socialization, are the most likely to distrust police, systems of criminal justice and Canadian institutions more generally. We theorize that, contrary to prevailing opinions regarding the ways in which distrust in Black communities stems from wariness of law enforcement in home countries, Canadian system avoidance is led by Black people who are from Canada.
加拿大的黑人刑事定罪问题以及他们对刑事司法系统的相对不信任是既定事实。在这里,我们对这一说法中隐含的黑人整体形象提出质疑。通过对“综合社会调查”中非洲出生移民的反应差异进行探究,我们借鉴了关于 1.5 代移民的现有理论,证明那些作为儿童抵达加拿大、在加拿大长大并接受加拿大教育、劳动力市场和其他社会化机构培养的黑人移民最有可能不信任警察、刑事司法系统以及更广泛的加拿大机构。我们的理论认为,与普遍认为的黑人社区的不信任态度源于对原籍国执法机构的警惕相反,加拿大制度的回避是由来自加拿大的黑人主导的。