Department of global public health and primary care, University of Bergen, Norway.
Research unit for general practice, NORCE Norwegian Research Centre, Bergen, Norway.
Scand J Prim Health Care. 2022 Sep;40(3):405-413. doi: 10.1080/02813432.2022.2139345. Epub 2022 Nov 8.
When patients suffer medically unexplained symptoms, consultations can be difficult and frustrating for both patient and GP. Acknowledging the patient as a co-subject can be particularly important when the symptoms remain unexplained. One way of seeing the patient as a co-subject is by recognizing any among their strong sides.
To explore GPs' experiences with discovering strengths in their patients with medically unexplained symptoms and elicit GPs' reflections on how this might be useful.
Four focus-groups with 17 GPs in Norway. Verbatim transcripts from the interviews were analyzed by systematic text condensation.
Recollecting patients' strengths was quiet challenging to the GPs. Gradually they nevertheless shared a range of examples, and many participants had experienced that knowing patients' strong sides could make consultations less demanding, and sometimes enable the GP to provide better help. Identifying strengths in patients with unexplained symptoms required a deliberate effort on the GPs' behalf, and this seemed to be a result of a strong focus on biomedical disease and loss of function.
Acknowledging patients' strong sides can bolster GPs' ability to help patients with medically unexplained symptoms. However, the epistemic disadvantage of generalist expertise makes this hard to achieve. It is difficult for GPs to integrate person-centered perspectives with biomedical knowledge due to the privileged position of the latter. This seems to indicate a need for system-level innovations to increase the status of person-centered clinical work. Key pointsMUS is challenging for both patients and GPs mainly because of the incongruence between symptoms and the dominating biomedical model.GPs' focus on pathology and loss of function can prevent them from discovering patients' strengths.Awareness of patients' strengths can make consultations less demanding for GPs and enable them to provide better help.A conscious effort is needed to discover patients' strengths.
当患者出现无法用医学解释的症状时,医患双方的咨询都可能变得困难和令人沮丧。当症状仍无法解释时,承认患者是共同主体可能尤为重要。将患者视为共同主体的一种方式是认识到他们的强项。
探讨全科医生在发现有无法用医学解释症状的患者的强项方面的经验,并了解他们认为这有何作用。
在挪威,对 17 名全科医生进行了 4 次焦点小组讨论。对访谈的逐字记录进行了系统文本浓缩分析。
对全科医生来说,回忆患者的强项颇具挑战性。但他们逐渐分享了一系列实例,许多参与者的经验表明,了解患者的强项可以使咨询变得不那么费力,有时还能让医生提供更好的帮助。在无法用医学解释症状的患者中识别强项需要全科医生付出深思熟虑的努力,这似乎是由于他们过分关注生物医学疾病和功能丧失的结果。
承认患者的强项可以增强全科医生对有无法用医学解释症状的患者的帮助能力。然而,通才专长的认识论劣势使这难以实现。由于后者的特权地位,全科医生很难将以患者为中心的观点与生物医学知识相结合。这似乎表明需要进行系统层面的创新,以提高以患者为中心的临床工作的地位。
主要由于症状与占主导地位的生物医学模式之间的不匹配,肌痛性脑脊髓炎(MUS)对患者和全科医生来说都是一种挑战。
全科医生对病理学和功能丧失的关注可能会阻止他们发现患者的强项。
意识到患者的强项可以减轻全科医生的咨询负担,并使他们能够提供更好的帮助。
发现患者的强项需要有意识的努力。