Nevéus Tryggve
Department of Women's and Children's Health, Uppsala University, Uppsala, Sweden.
Front Pediatr. 2022 Nov 4;10:1044302. doi: 10.3389/fped.2022.1044302. eCollection 2022.
Much has happened since the end of the era when enuresis was blamed on the parents or the children themselves. Still, there are large gaps in our knowledge and large parts of modern enuresis management guidelines are (still) not based on firm evidence. In this review I will question the following commonly made assumptions regarding enuresis evaluation and treatment: •It is important to subdivide enuresis according to the presence of daytime symptoms•Voiding charts are crucial in the primary evaluation of the enuretic child•All children with enuresis need to be screened for behavioral or psychiatric issues•Concomittant daytime incontinence needs to be successfully treated before addressing the enuresis•Concomittant constipation needs to be successfully treated before addressing the enuresis•Urotherapy is a first-line treatment against enuresis In this review I will argue that much of what we do with these children is based more on experience and well-meant but poorly supported assumptions than on evidence. Some advice and therapies are probably ineffective whereas for other treatments we lack reliable predictors of treatment response. More research is obviously needed, but awaiting new results enuresis management could be substantially simplified.
自从尿床被归咎于父母或孩子自身的那个时代结束以来,已经发生了很多事情。然而,我们的认知仍存在很大差距,现代尿床管理指南的很大一部分(仍然)并非基于确凿证据。在这篇综述中,我将质疑以下关于尿床评估和治疗的常见假设:
根据白天症状的有无对尿床进行细分很重要
排尿图表在尿床儿童的初步评估中至关重要
所有尿床儿童都需要筛查行为或精神问题
在解决尿床问题之前,需要成功治疗伴随的白天尿失禁
在解决尿床问题之前,需要成功治疗伴随的便秘
尿疗法是治疗尿床的一线疗法
在这篇综述中,我将指出,我们对这些孩子所做的很多事情更多是基于经验以及善意但缺乏有力支持的假设,而非证据。一些建议和疗法可能无效,而对于其他治疗方法,我们缺乏可靠的治疗反应预测指标。显然需要更多研究,但在等待新结果的同时,尿床管理可以大幅简化。