Fu Jia, Shen Xiaoying, Anderson Mark, Stec Michael, Petratos Tia, Cloherty Gavin, Montefiori David C, Landay Alan, Moy James N
Division of Allergy and Immunology and Division of Gerontology, Department of Internal Medicine, Rush University Medical Center, Rush University, Chicago, IL 60302, USA.
Department of Surgery, Duke Human Vaccine Institute, Duke University Medical Center, Durham, NC 27710, USA.
Vaccines (Basel). 2022 Nov 11;10(11):1904. doi: 10.3390/vaccines10111904.
In vaccine clinical trials, both binding antibody (bAb) levels and neutralization antibody (nAb) titers have been shown to be correlates of SARS-CoV-2 vaccine efficacy. We report a strong correlation bAb and nAb responses against the SARS-CoV-2 Omicron (BA.1) variant in infection-naïve and previously infected (convalescent) individuals after one and two doses of BNT162b2 vaccination. The vaccine-induced bAb levels against Omicron were significantly lower compared to previous variants of concern in both infection-naive and convalescent individuals, with the convalescent individuals showing significantly higher bAb compared to the naïve individuals at all timepoints. The finding that bAb highly correlated with nAb provides evidence for utilizing binding antibody assays as a surrogate for neutralizing antibody assays. Our data also revealed that after full vaccination, a higher percentage of individuals had undetectable Omicron nAb (58.6% in naive individuals, 7.4% in convalescent individuals) compared to the percentage of individuals who had negative Omicron bAb (0% in naive individuals, 0% in convalescent individuals). The discordance between bAb and nAb activities and the high degree of immune escape by Omicron may explain the high frequency of Omicron infections after vaccination.
在疫苗临床试验中,结合抗体(bAb)水平和中和抗体(nAb)滴度均已被证明是SARS-CoV-2疫苗效力的相关指标。我们报告了在未感染过新冠病毒的个体以及既往感染过(康复期)的个体中,接种一剂和两剂BNT162b2疫苗后,针对SARS-CoV-2奥密克戎(BA.1)变异株的bAb和nAb反应之间存在强相关性。在未感染过新冠病毒的个体和康复期个体中,与先前令人担忧的变异株相比,疫苗诱导的针对奥密克戎的bAb水平显著降低,在所有时间点,康复期个体的bAb水平均显著高于未感染过新冠病毒的个体。bAb与nAb高度相关这一发现为利用结合抗体检测作为中和抗体检测的替代方法提供了证据。我们的数据还显示,与奥密克戎bAb呈阴性的个体比例(未感染过新冠病毒的个体中为0%,康复期个体中为0%)相比,在全程接种疫苗后,有更高比例的个体检测不到奥密克戎nAb(未感染过新冠病毒的个体中为58.6%,康复期个体中为7.4%)。bAb和nAb活性之间的不一致以及奥密克戎的高度免疫逃逸可能解释了接种疫苗后奥密克戎感染的高频率。