Ramírez-Sevilla C, Gómez-Lanza E, Llopis-Manzanera J, Cetina-Herrando A, Puyol-Pallàs J M
Hospital Sant Joan de Déu de Martorell, Martorell, Barcelona, Spain.
Hospital Moisés Broggi, Sant Joan Despí, Barcelona, Spain.
Actas Urol Esp (Engl Ed). 2023 Jan-Feb;47(1):27-33. doi: 10.1016/j.acuroe.2022.08.016. Epub 2022 Aug 12.
The objective of this study was to compare the results on prevention of uncomplicated recurrent UTI between continuous use of antibiotics, MV140 autovaccine and MV140 polybacterial vaccine from collection strain.
377 patients were prospectively analyzed from January 2017 to August 2019 and divided into 3 groups according to the prophylaxis. Group A (126): antibiotics, Group B (126): MV140 autovaccine, Group C (125): MV140 polybacterial vaccine from the collection strain. Variables analyzed were: gender, age, menopause, number of UTI at baseline and 3 and 6 months after the end of prophylaxis, health cost along follow-up at 3 and 6 months.
At 3 months, group A had 0-1 UTI in 65%, group B had 0-1 UTI in 80.8% and group C in 81.7%. At 6 months, group A had 0-1 UTI in 44.4%, group B had 0-1 UTI in 61.6% and group C in 74.6%. Regarding health cost along follow-up, at 3 months group A had euro21,171.87, group B had euro20,763.73 and group C euro18,866.14. At 6 months, health cost was euro32,980.35 in group A, euro28,133.42 in group B, and euro23,629.19 in group C.
MV140 autovaccine and MV140 polybacterial vaccine were more efficient with lower number of UTI at 3 and 6 months and lower health cost along follow-up compared to continued prophylaxis with antibiotics (p < 0.05). Polybacterial MV140 vaccine from collection strain had higher effect to reduce the number of UTI and less health cost than autovaccine.
本研究的目的是比较持续使用抗生素、MV140自身疫苗和来自收集菌株的MV140多细菌疫苗在预防非复杂性复发性尿路感染方面的效果。
对2017年1月至2019年8月期间的377例患者进行前瞻性分析,并根据预防措施将其分为3组。A组(126例):抗生素组;B组(126例):MV140自身疫苗组;C组(125例):来自收集菌株的MV140多细菌疫苗组。分析的变量包括:性别、年龄、绝经情况、基线时以及预防结束后3个月和6个月时的尿路感染次数、随访3个月和6个月时的健康成本。
在3个月时,A组65%的患者有0 - 1次尿路感染,B组为80.8%,C组为81.7%。在6个月时,A组44.4%的患者有0 - 1次尿路感染,B组为61.6%,C组为74.6%。关于随访期间的健康成本,3个月时A组为21,171.87欧元,B组为20,763.73欧元,C组为18,866.14欧元。6个月时,A组的健康成本为32,980.35欧元,B组为28,133.42欧元,C组为23,629.19欧元。
与持续使用抗生素进行预防相比,MV140自身疫苗和MV140多细菌疫苗在3个月和6个月时尿路感染次数更少,随访期间健康成本更低,效果更佳(p < 0.05)。来自收集菌株的多细菌MV140疫苗在减少尿路感染次数方面比自身疫苗效果更好,且健康成本更低。