Department of Internal Medicine, American University of Beirut, Beirut 11 0236, Lebanon.
Department of Internal Medicine, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI 48109, USA.
J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2023 Feb 15;108(3):507-528. doi: 10.1210/clinem/dgac621.
Hypercalcemia of malignancy (HCM) is the most common metabolic complication of malignancies, but its incidence may be declining due to potent chemotherapeutic agents. The high mortality associated with HCM has declined markedly due to the introduction of increasingly effective chemotherapeutic drugs. Despite the widespread availability of efficacious medications to treat HCM, evidence-based recommendations to manage this debilitating condition are lacking.
To develop guidelines for the treatment of adults with HCM.
A multidisciplinary panel of clinical experts, together with experts in systematic literature review, identified and prioritized 8 clinical questions related to the treatment of HCM in adult patients. The systematic reviews (SRs) queried electronic databases for studies relevant to the selected questions. The Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE) methodology was used to assess the certainty of evidence and make recommendations. An independent SR was conducted in parallel to assess patients' and physicians' values and preferences, costs, resources needed, acceptability, feasibility, equity, and other domains relevant to the Evidence-to-Decision framework as well as to enable judgements and recommendations.
The panel recommends (strong recommendation) in adults with HCM treatment with denosumab (Dmab) or an intravenous (IV) bisphosphonate (BP). The following recommendations were based on low certainty of the evidence. The panel suggests (conditional recommendation) (1) in adults with HCM, the use of Dmab rather than an IV BP; (2) in adults with severe HCM, a combination of calcitonin and an IV BP or Dmab therapy as initial treatment; and (3) in adults with refractory/recurrent HCM despite treatment with BP, the use of Dmab. The panel suggests (conditional recommendation) the addition of an IV BP or Dmab in adult patients with hypercalcemia due to tumors associated with high calcitriol levels who are already receiving glucocorticoid therapy but continue to have severe or symptomatic HCM. The panel suggests (conditional recommendation) in adult patients with hypercalcemia due to parathyroid carcinoma, treatment with either a calcimimetic or an antiresorptive (IV BP or Dmab). The panel judges the treatments as probably accessible and feasible for most recommendations but noted variability in costs, resources required, and their impact on equity.
The panel's recommendations are based on currently available evidence considering the most important outcomes in HCM to patients and key stakeholders. Treatment of the primary malignancy is instrumental for controlling hypercalcemia and preventing its recurrence. The recommendations provide a framework for the medical management of adults with HCM and incorporate important decisional and contextual factors. The guidelines underscore current knowledge gaps that can be used to establish future research agendas.
恶性肿瘤相关性高钙血症(HCM)是恶性肿瘤最常见的代谢并发症,但由于强效化疗药物的应用,其发病率可能正在下降。由于越来越有效的化疗药物的应用,与 HCM 相关的高死亡率已显著下降。尽管有治疗 HCM 的有效药物广泛应用,但缺乏针对这种使人虚弱的疾病的循证推荐。
制定治疗成人 HCM 的指南。
一个由临床专家和系统文献综述专家组成的多学科小组,确定并优先考虑了 8 个与成人 HCM 治疗相关的临床问题。系统综述(SR)查询了与选定问题相关的电子数据库中的研究。使用推荐评估、制定与评估分级(GRADE)方法评估证据的确定性并提出建议。同时进行了一项独立的 SR,以评估患者和医生的价值观和偏好、成本、所需资源、可接受性、可行性、公平性以及与证据决策框架相关的其他领域,以便进行判断和建议。
专家组建议(强烈推荐)在 HCM 成人患者中使用地舒单抗(Dmab)或静脉(IV)双膦酸盐(BP)治疗。以下建议基于证据的确定性低。专家组建议(有条件推荐)(1)在 HCM 成人患者中,使用 Dmab 而不是 IV BP;(2)在严重 HCM 成人患者中,将降钙素与 IV BP 或 Dmab 联合作为初始治疗;(3)在接受 BP 治疗后仍有 HCM 复发/难治性的 HCM 成人患者中,使用 Dmab。专家组建议(有条件推荐)在因甲状旁腺癌导致高钙血症且血钙水平高、已接受糖皮质激素治疗但仍有严重或症状性 HCM 的肿瘤相关患者中,加用 IV BP 或 Dmab。专家组建议(有条件推荐)在因甲状旁腺癌导致高钙血症的患者中,使用钙敏感受体激动剂或骨吸收抑制剂(IV BP 或 Dmab)治疗。专家组判断这些治疗方法对于大多数建议都是可及且可行的,但指出了成本、所需资源及其对公平性的影响存在差异。
专家组的建议基于目前对 HCM 患者和关键利益相关者最重要结局的可用证据。治疗原发性恶性肿瘤对于控制高钙血症和预防其复发至关重要。该建议为成人 HCM 的医学管理提供了一个框架,并纳入了重要的决策和背景因素。该指南强调了当前的知识差距,这些差距可用于制定未来的研究议程。