Shearn Christina, Krockow Eva M
School of Psychology and Vision Sciences, University of Leicester, University Road, Leicester, LE1 7RH, UK.
SSM Qual Res Health. 2023 Jun;3:100210. doi: 10.1016/j.ssmqr.2022.100210. Epub 2022 Dec 22.
Despite being disproportionately affected by the COVID-19 pandemic, ethnic and racial minority groups show widespread vaccine hesitancy. Adherence to ongoing booster vaccine campaigns is required to contain future spread of the virus and protect health systems. This review aims to appraise and synthesise qualitative studies published from December 2021 to February 2022 addressing the issue for an in-depth exploration of initial COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy in minorities, including refugee, asylum seeker and migrant populations. A systematic literature search of five databases identified 15 eligible studies. Thematic synthesis identified three main themes of "institutional mistrust", "lack of confidence in vaccine and vaccine development process", and "lack of reliable information or messengers". Two minor themes included "complacency/perceived lack of need" and "structural barriers to vaccine access". "Institutional mistrust" permeated several other themes, demonstrating the need for culturally sensitive approaches. Applying our findings to the World Health Organisation's Three C Model of vaccine hesitancy, the "confidence" dimension appears to represent a disproportionately large barrier to vaccine uptake in ethnic minority groups. Indeed, nuanced adaptations of the model may be necessary to explain vaccine hesitancy in those groups. Further research is required to explore factors facilitating vaccine uptake to monitor changes in hesitancy over time.
尽管少数族裔和种族群体在新冠疫情中受到的影响尤为严重,但他们对疫苗普遍持犹豫态度。为了遏制病毒未来的传播并保护卫生系统,需要持续开展加强疫苗接种运动。本综述旨在评估和综合2021年12月至2022年2月发表的定性研究,以深入探讨少数群体(包括难民、寻求庇护者和移民群体)最初对新冠疫苗的犹豫态度。对五个数据库进行系统的文献检索,确定了15项符合条件的研究。主题综合分析确定了三个主要主题:“对机构的不信任”、“对疫苗及疫苗研发过程缺乏信心”以及“缺乏可靠信息或信息传递者”。另外两个次要主题包括“自满/认为没有必要”和“疫苗接种的结构障碍”。“对机构的不信任”贯穿其他几个主题,这表明需要采用文化敏感方法。将我们的研究结果应用于世界卫生组织的疫苗犹豫三要素模型,“信心”维度似乎是少数族裔群体接种疫苗的一个特别大的障碍。事实上,可能需要对该模型进行细致调整,以解释这些群体中的疫苗犹豫现象。需要进一步研究以探索促进疫苗接种的因素,并监测犹豫态度随时间的变化。