Nemani Venu M, Louie Philip K, Drolet Caroline E, Rhee John M
Center for Neurosciences and Spine and Department of Neurosurgery, Virginia Mason Franciscan Health, Seattle, WA, USA.
Departments of Orthopaedic Surgery and Neurosurgery, The Emory Spine Center, Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, GA, USA.
Neurospine. 2022 Dec;19(4):876-882. doi: 10.14245/ns.2244924.462. Epub 2022 Dec 31.
It remains unclear whether cervical sagittal deformity (CSD) should be defined by radiographic parameters alone versus both clinical and radiographic factors, and whether radiographic malalignment by itself warrants a CSD corrective surgery in patients who present primarily with neurologic symptoms.
We administered a survey to a group of expert surgeons to evaluate whether radiographic parameters alone were sufficient to diagnose CSD, and in which scenarios surgeons recommend a CSD realignment procedure versus addressing the neurologic symptoms alone.
No single radiographic criteria reached a 50% threshold as being sufficient to establish the diagnosis of CSD. When asymptomatic radiographic malalignment was present, a sagittal deformity correction was more likely to be recommended in patients with myelopathy versus those with radiculopathy alone. The majority of surgeons recommended deformity correction when symptoms of cervical deformity were present in addition to radiographic malalignment (85% with deformity symptoms and radiculopathy, 93% with deformity symptoms and myelopathy).
There is no consensus on which radiographic and/or clinical criteria are necessary to define the presence of CSD. We recommend that symptoms of cervical deformity, in addition to radiographic parameters, be considered when deciding whether to perform deformity correction in patients who present primarily with myelopathy or radiculopathy.
目前尚不清楚颈椎矢状面畸形(CSD)是否应仅通过影像学参数来定义,还是应结合临床和影像学因素来定义;对于主要表现为神经症状的患者,影像学排列不齐本身是否足以成为CSD矫正手术的指征。
我们对一组专家外科医生进行了一项调查,以评估仅通过影像学参数是否足以诊断CSD,以及在哪些情况下外科医生会推荐进行CSD矫正手术,而不是仅处理神经症状。
没有单一的影像学标准达到足以确立CSD诊断的50%阈值。当存在无症状的影像学排列不齐时,与仅患有神经根病的患者相比,脊髓病患者更有可能被推荐进行矢状面畸形矫正。当除影像学排列不齐外还存在颈椎畸形症状时,大多数外科医生推荐进行畸形矫正(畸形症状合并神经根病的患者中85%,畸形症状合并脊髓病的患者中93%)。
对于定义CSD的存在需要哪些影像学和/或临床标准,目前尚无共识。我们建议,对于主要表现为脊髓病或神经根病的患者,在决定是否进行畸形矫正时,除了影像学参数外,还应考虑颈椎畸形症状。