Tempelaar Wanda, Kozloff Nicole, Crawford Allison, Voineskos Aristotle, Addington Don, Alexander Tallan, Baluyut Crystal, Bromley Sarah, Brooks Sandy, de Freitas Lauren, Jindani Seharish, Kirvan Anne, Morizio Andrea, Polillo Alexia, Roby Rachel, Sosnowski Alexandra, Villanueva Victoria, Durbin Janet, Barwick Melanie
Slaight Family Centre for Youth in Transition, Centre for Addiction and Mental Health, Toronto, ON, Canada.
Department of Psychiatry, Faculty of Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada.
Front Health Serv. 2023 Feb 3;2:995392. doi: 10.3389/frhs.2022.995392. eCollection 2022.
Team-based Early Psychosis Intervention (EPI) services is standard of care for youth with psychosis. The COVID-19 pandemic required most EPI services to mount an unplanned, rapid pivot to virtual delivery with limited guidance on how to deliver virtual clinical services or whether quality of re-implementation and treatment outcomes would be impacted. We used a structured approach to identify essential modifications for the delivery of core components and explored facilitators and barriers for re-implementation and fidelity of a virtually delivered EPI intervention.
NAVIGATE is a structured approach to team-based EPI. It provides detailed modules to guide delivery of core components including medication management, psychoeducation and psychotherapies, supported employment/education, and family education. Having initially implemented NAVIGATE at the Centre for Addiction and Mental Health (CAMH) in 2017, the EPI service transitioned to virtual delivery amid the COVID pandemic. Using a practice profile developed to support implementation, we detailed how core components of NAVIGATE were rapidly modified for virtual delivery as reported in structured group meetings with clinicians. The Framework for Reporting Adaptations and Modifications for Evidence-Based Interventions (FRAME) was used to describe modifications. Fidelity to the EPI standards of care was assessed by the First Episode Psychosis Fidelity Scale (FEPS-FS). Re-implementation barriers and facilitators and subsequent mitigation strategies were explored using structured clinician interviews guided by the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research (CFIR).
Identified modifications related to the intervention process, context, and training. We identified contextual factors affecting the re-implementation of virtually delivered NAVIGATE and then documented mitigating strategies that addressed these barriers. Findings can inform the implementation of virtual EPI services elsewhere, including guidance on processes, training and technology, and approaches to providing care virtually.
This study identified modifications, impacts and mitigations to barriers emerging from rapid, unplanned virtual delivery of EPI services. These findings can support delivery of high-quality virtual services to youth with psychosis when virtual care is indicated.
基于团队的早期精神病干预(EPI)服务是精神病青年的标准治疗方式。新冠疫情要求大多数EPI服务在没有关于如何提供虚拟临床服务或重新实施的质量及治疗结果是否会受到影响的有限指导的情况下,进行无计划的、迅速的向虚拟服务的转变。我们采用一种结构化方法来确定核心组成部分交付的必要修改,并探索重新实施以及虚拟交付的EPI干预的保真度的促进因素和障碍。
NAVIGATE是一种基于团队的EPI的结构化方法。它提供详细的模块来指导核心组成部分的交付,包括药物管理、心理教育和心理治疗、支持性就业/教育以及家庭教育。2017年,EPI服务最初在成瘾与心理健康中心(CAMH)实施了NAVIGATE,在新冠疫情期间转向了虚拟服务。利用为支持实施而制定的实践概况,我们详细说明了在与临床医生的结构化小组会议中报告的NAVIGATE核心组成部分如何为虚拟交付而迅速修改。采用基于证据的干预措施的报告改编和修改框架(FRAME)来描述修改情况。通过首发精神病保真度量表(FEPS-FS)评估对EPI护理标准的保真度。使用实施研究综合框架(CFIR)指导的结构化临床医生访谈,探索重新实施的障碍和促进因素以及随后的缓解策略。
确定的修改与干预过程、背景和培训有关。我们确定了影响虚拟交付的NAVIGATE重新实施的背景因素,然后记录了解决这些障碍的缓解策略。研究结果可为其他地方虚拟EPI服务的实施提供参考,包括有关流程、培训和技术的指导,以及虚拟提供护理的方法。
本研究确定了EPI服务快速、无计划的虚拟交付所产生的修改、影响和障碍缓解措施。这些研究结果可支持在需要虚拟护理时为患有精神病的青年提供高质量的虚拟服务。