Zhuang Y F, Xu S Z, Wang Z F, Ding Z J, Zhang S F, Yan F, Cai J C
Department of Gastrointestinal Surgery, Gastrointestinal Tumor Institute of Xiamen University School of Medicine, Xiamen Key Laboratory of Gastrointestinal Tumor, Zhongshan Hospital, Xiamen University, Xiamen 361004, China.
Zhonghua Wei Chang Wai Ke Za Zhi. 2023 Apr 25;26(4):357-364. doi: 10.3760/cma.j.cn441530-20221119-00476.
To investigate the feasibility of Cai tube-assisted natural orifice specimen extraction surgery (NOSES) in gastrointestinal surgery. This was a descriptive case-series study. Inclusion criteria: (1) colorectal or gastric cancer diagnosed by preoperative pathological examination or redundant sigmoid or transverse colon detected by barium enema; (2) indications for laparoscopic surgery; (3) body mass index <30 kg/m (transanal surgery) and 35 kg/m (transvaginal surgery); (4) no vaginal stenosis or adhesions in female patients undergoing transvaginal specimen extraction; and (5) patients with redundant colon aged 18-70 years and a history of intractable constipation for more than 10 years. Exclusion criteria: (1) colorectal cancer with intestinal perforation or obstruction, or gastric cancer with gastric perforation, gastric hemorrhage, or pyloric obstruction; (2) simultaneous resection of lung, bone, or liver metastases ; (3) history of major abdominal surgery or intestinal adhesions; and (4) incomplete clinical data. From January 2014 to October 2022, 209 patients with gastrointestinal tumors and 25 with redundant colons who met the above criteria were treated by NOSES utilizing a Cai tube (China invention patent number:ZL201410168748.2) in the Department of Gastrointestinal Surgery, Zhongshan Hospital, Xiamen University. The procedures included eversion and pull-out NOSES radical resection in 14 patients with middle and low rectal cancer, NOSES radical left hemicolectomy in 171 patients with left-sided colorectal cancer, NOSES radical right hemicolectomy in 12 patients with right-sided colon cancer, NOSES systematic mesogastric resection in 12 patients with gastric cancer, and NOSES subtotal colectomy in 25 patients with redundant colons. All specimens were collected by using an in-house-made anal cannula (Cai tube) with no auxiliary incisions. The primary outcomes included 1-year recurrence-free survival (RFS) and postoperative complications. Among 234 patients, 116 were male and 118 were female. The mean age was (56.6±10.9) years. NOSES was successfully completed in all patients without conversion to open surgery or procedure-related death. The negative rate of circumferential resection margin was 98.8% (169/171) with both two positive cases having left-sided colorectal cancer. Postoperative complications occurred in 37 patients (15.8%), including 11 cases (4.7%) of anastomotic leakage, 3 cases(1.3%) of anastomotic bleeding, 2 cases (0.9%) of intraperitoneal bleeding, 4 cases (1.7%) of abdominal infection, and 8 cases (3.4%) of pulmonary infection. Reoperations were required in 7 patients (3.0%), all of whom consented to creation of an ileostomy after anastomotic leakage. The total readmission rate within 30 days after surgery was 0.9% (2/234). After a follow-up of (18.3±3.6) months, the 1-year RFS was 94.7%. Five of 209 patients (2.4%) with gastrointestinal tumors had local recurrence, all of which was anastomotic recurrence. Sixteen patients (7.7%) developed distant metastases, including liver metastases(=8), lung metastases(=6), and bone metastases (=2). NOSES assisted by Cai tube is feasible and safe in radical resection of gastrointestinal tumors and subtotal colectomy for redundant colon.
探讨蔡氏管辅助经自然腔道取标本手术(NOSES)在胃肠外科手术中的可行性。这是一项描述性病例系列研究。纳入标准:(1)经术前病理检查确诊为结直肠癌或胃癌,或经钡剂灌肠检查发现乙状结肠或横结肠冗长;(2)有腹腔镜手术指征;(3)体重指数<30kg/m²(经肛门手术)和<35kg/m²(经阴道手术);(4)行经阴道取标本的女性患者无阴道狭窄或粘连;(5)结肠冗长患者年龄在18 - 70岁之间,且有超过10年的顽固性便秘病史。排除标准:(1)伴有肠穿孔或肠梗阻的结直肠癌,或伴有胃穿孔、胃出血或幽门梗阻的胃癌;(2)同时存在肺、骨或肝转移需行切除术;(3)有腹部大手术史或肠粘连史;(4)临床资料不完整。2014年1月至2022年10月,厦门大学附属中山医院胃肠外科对209例符合上述标准的胃肠肿瘤患者和25例结肠冗长患者采用蔡氏管(中国发明专利号:ZL201410168748.2)行NOSES手术。手术方式包括14例中低位直肠癌患者行外翻拖出式NOSES根治性切除术,171例左侧结直肠癌患者行NOSES根治性左半结肠切除术,12例右侧结肠癌患者行NOSES根治性右半结肠切除术,12例胃癌患者行NOSES系统性胃系膜切除术,25例结肠冗长患者行NOSES结肠次全切除术。所有标本均使用自制肛门插管(蔡氏管)收集,无辅助切口。主要观察指标包括1年无复发生存率(RFS)和术后并发症。234例患者中,男性116例,女性118例。平均年龄为(56.6±10.9)岁。所有患者均成功完成NOSES手术,无中转开腹或手术相关死亡。环周切缘阴性率为98.8%(169/171),2例阳性病例均为左侧结直肠癌。术后37例患者(15.8%)发生并发症, 其中吻合口漏11例(4.7%),吻合口出血3例(1.3%),腹腔内出血2例(0.9%),腹腔感染4例(1.7%),肺部感染8例(3.4%)。7例患者(3.0%)需要再次手术,均在吻合口漏后同意行回肠造口术。术后30天内总再入院率为0.9%(2/234)。随访(18.3±3.6)个月后,1年RFS为94.7%。209例胃肠肿瘤患者中有5例(2.4%)发生局部复发,均为吻合口复发。16例患者(7.7%)发生远处转移,包括肝转移(n = 8)、肺转移(n = 6)和骨转移(n = 2)。蔡氏管辅助的NOSES在胃肠肿瘤根治性切除和结肠冗长患者的结肠次全切除术中可行且安全。