Senyei Grant, Nobari Matthew, Miller Russell, Harrell Brody, Cheng George Z
Division of Pulmonary, Critical Care, and Sleep Medicine, University of California San Diego, La Jolla, CA 92037, USA.
Department of Pulmonary Medicine, Naval Medical Center San Diego, San Diego, CA 92134, USA.
Life (Basel). 2023 Apr 3;13(4):936. doi: 10.3390/life13040936.
The number of procedures required to attain proficiency with new bronchoscopic biopsy technologies for peripheral pulmonary lesions (PPLs) is uncertain. A prospective, single-center study evaluated learning curves of two operators performing PPL biopsies using a novel, real-time, intraoperative tomographic imaging system in consecutive procedures in adults with CT-detected PPLs. Operators were considered "proficient" when they asked three or fewer questions of the manufacturer's clinical representative with no subsequent navigations in which they asked more than three questions. A total of 31 procedures were performed on 31 patients (Operator 1: 18, Operator 2: 13). Proficiency was achieved after an average of 10 procedures (Operator 1: 12, Operator 2: 8). From the learning curve to the post-learning curve period, the number of questions (median [IQR]: 23 [9.5-41.5] versus 0 [0-1], < 0.001) and radiation dose (median [IQR]: 19.5 mGy/m [1.9-43.5] versus 1.5 mGy/m [0.7-3.3], = 0.05) decreased significantly; procedure time decreased (median [IQR]: 12 min [7-20] versus 8 min [3-15], = 0.29); and diagnostic yield increased significantly (13/20 cases [65%] to 11/11 cases [100%]), ( = 0.03). Based on this unique, clinically relevant method of assessing learning curve, proficiency with the Body Vision system was achieved at approximately the tenth procedure. These findings require validation in larger, diverse populations.
掌握用于周围型肺部病变(PPL)的新型支气管镜活检技术所需的操作次数尚不确定。一项前瞻性单中心研究评估了两名操作者使用一种新型实时术中断层成像系统对CT检测到的PPL成年患者进行连续PPL活检的学习曲线。当操作者向制造商的临床代表提问三个或更少问题,且后续操作中提问不超过三个问题时,即被视为“熟练”。共对31例患者进行了31次操作(操作者1:18次,操作者2:13次)。平均10次操作后达到熟练水平(操作者1:12次,操作者2:8次)。从学习曲线阶段到学习后曲线阶段,问题数量(中位数[四分位间距]:23[9.5 - 41.5]对0[0 - 1],<0.001)和辐射剂量(中位数[四分位间距]:19.5 mGy/m[1.9 - 43.5]对1.5 mGy/m[0.7 - 3.3],P = 0.05)显著降低;操作时间减少(中位数[四分位间距]:12分钟[7 - 20]对8分钟[3 - 15],P = 0.29);诊断率显著提高(20例中的13例[65%]至11例中的11例[100%]),(P = 0.03)。基于这种独特的、与临床相关的评估学习曲线的方法,大约在第十次操作时达到了对Body Vision系统的熟练掌握。这些发现需要在更大、更多样化的人群中进行验证。