Trager Robert J, Makineni Pratheek S, Williamson Timothy J
Chiropractic, Connor Whole Health, University Hospitals Cleveland Medical Center, Cleveland, USA.
Medicine, Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, USA.
Cureus. 2023 Apr 6;15(4):e37216. doi: 10.7759/cureus.37216. eCollection 2023 Apr.
The number and characteristics of patients with previous spine surgery receiving chiropractic spinal manipulation (CSM) are largely unknown. This study aimed to explore the proportion of patients receiving CSM with a history of spine surgery, the characteristics of these patients, and the treatments received compared to a broader population of patients receiving CSM.
We queried a 110-million-patient United States (US) network of aggregated records and claims data from patients attending integrated academic health centers (TriNetX, Inc.) on March 6, 2023, yielding data spanning 2013-2023. We identified two patient groups: (1) those receiving CSM and (2) a subset receiving CSM with prior spine surgery. We compared baseline characteristics and treatments received over a one-year follow-up after CSM.
Of the 81,291 patients receiving CSM, 8,808 (10.8%) had at least one prior spine surgery. Patients with prior spine surgery receiving CSM were older, more often female, more often non-Hispanic/Latino and White, less often Black, had a greater body mass index, and had a higher prevalence of low back and neck pain compared to the broader CSM cohort (<0.0001 for each). Those with prior spine surgery were also more likely to receive multiple medications, physiotherapy procedures, and spinal injections (<0.0001 for each).
Patients receiving CSM with a history of spine surgery comprise a substantial proportion of CSM patients in large US academic health centers. This subset of patients differs characteristically from the broader CSM population and more often receives medications, physiotherapy, and spinal injections. Further research is needed to examine the safety and efficacy of CSM in this population, given the high proportion of patients and limited research on this topic.
接受脊椎按摩疗法(CSM)的既往脊柱手术患者的数量和特征在很大程度上尚不清楚。本研究旨在探讨有脊柱手术史的接受CSM治疗的患者比例、这些患者的特征,以及与更广泛的接受CSM治疗的患者群体相比所接受的治疗。
我们查询了一个拥有1.1亿患者的美国综合记录和索赔数据库(TriNetX公司),该数据库来自于2023年3月6日就诊于综合学术健康中心的患者,数据涵盖2013 - 2023年。我们确定了两组患者:(1)接受CSM治疗的患者;(2)接受CSM治疗且有既往脊柱手术史的患者子集。我们比较了CSM治疗后一年随访期间的基线特征和接受的治疗。
在81291例接受CSM治疗的患者中,8808例(10.8%)至少有一次既往脊柱手术。与更广泛的CSM队列相比,有既往脊柱手术史且接受CSM治疗的患者年龄更大、女性更多、非西班牙裔/拉丁裔和白人更多、黑人更少、体重指数更高,且腰背痛和颈痛的患病率更高(每项均<0.0001)。有既往脊柱手术史的患者也更有可能接受多种药物、物理治疗程序和脊柱注射(每项均<0.0001)。
在美国大型学术健康中心,有脊柱手术史且接受CSM治疗的患者占CSM患者的相当比例。这一患者子集在特征上与更广泛的CSM人群不同,且更常接受药物、物理治疗和脊柱注射。鉴于该患者群体比例高且对此主题的研究有限,需要进一步研究以检验CSM在该人群中的安全性和有效性。