Hebel Nathan S D, Boonipat Thanapoom, Lin Jason, Shapiro Daniel, Bite Uldis
Aesthet Surg J Open Forum. 2023 Mar 28;5:ojad032. doi: 10.1093/asjof/ojad032. eCollection 2023.
Aesthetic facial surgeries historically rely on subjective analysis in determining success; this limits objective comparison of surgical outcomes.
This case study exemplifies the use of an artificial intelligence software on objectively analyzing facial rejuvenation techniques with the aim of reducing subjective bias.
Retrospectively, all patients who underwent facial rejuvenation surgery with concomitant procedures from 2015 to 2017 were included ( = 32). Patients were categorized into Groups A to C: Group A-10 superficial musculoaponeurotic system (SMAS) plication facelift ( = 10), Group B-SMASectomy facelift ( = 7), and Group C-high SMAS facelift ( = 15). Neutral repose images preoperatively and postoperatively (average >3 months) were analyzed using artificial intelligence for emotion and action unit alterations.
Postoperatively, Group A experienced a decrease in happiness by 0.84% and a decrease in anger by 6.87% ( >> .1). Group B had an increase in happiness by 0.77% and an increase in anger by 1.91% ( >> .1). Both Group A and Group B did not show any discernable action unit patterns. In Group C, the lip corner puller AU increased in average intensity from 0% to 18.7%. This correlated with an average increase in detected happiness from 1.03% to 13.17% ( = .008). Conversely, the average detected anger decreased from 14.66% to 0.63% ( = .032).
This study provides the first proof of concept for the use of a machine learning software application to objectively assess various aesthetic surgical outcomes in facial rejuvenation. Due to limitations in patient heterogeneity, this study does not claim one technique's superiority but serves as a conceptual foundation for future investigation.
从历史上看,面部美容手术在确定手术成功与否时依赖主观分析;这限制了手术结果的客观比较。
本案例研究展示了使用人工智能软件客观分析面部年轻化技术,以减少主观偏差。
回顾性纳入2015年至2017年接受面部年轻化手术及相关手术的所有患者(n = 32)。患者分为A至C组:A组 - 10例表浅肌肉腱膜系统(SMAS)折叠面部提升术(n = 10),B组 - SMAS切除术面部提升术(n = 7),C组 - 高位SMAS面部提升术(n = 15)。使用人工智能分析术前和术后(平均>3个月)的中性静息图像,以观察情绪和动作单元的变化。
术后,A组的快乐感下降0.84%,愤怒感下降6.87%(P >>.1)。B组的快乐感增加0.77%,愤怒感增加1.91%(P >>.1)。A组和B组均未显示出任何可辨别的动作单元模式。在C组中,唇角牵拉动作单元的平均强度从0%增加到18.7%。这与检测到的快乐感平均从1.03%增加到13.17%相关(P =.008)。相反,检测到的平均愤怒感从14.66%下降到0.63%(P =.032)。
本研究为使用机器学习软件应用客观评估面部年轻化中各种美容手术结果提供了首个概念验证。由于患者异质性的限制,本研究并未宣称一种技术的优越性,但为未来的研究奠定了概念基础。