United States Army, United States of America.
Psychology Department, Penn State Behrend, Erie, PA, United States of America.
J Affect Disord. 2023 Oct 1;338:207-219. doi: 10.1016/j.jad.2023.06.011. Epub 2023 Jun 7.
After experiencing a traumatic event, two possible outcomes are experiencing positive changes, such as posttraumatic growth (PTG), and/or experiencing distress in the form of posttraumatic stress symptoms (PTSS). These constructs are not mutually exclusive; those who experience PTSS may concurrently or at a later date likewise undergo PTG. Pretrauma factors, such as personality as measured by the Big Five Inventory (BFI), can interact with both PTSS and PTG.
The present study utilized Network theory to examine the interactions between PTSS, PTG, and personality in 1310 participants. Three networks were computed (PTSS, PTSS/BFI, PTSS/PTG/BFI).
Within the PTSS network, strong negative emotions emerged as the strongest influence on the network. Again, in the PTSS and BFI network, strong negative emotions exerted the strongest overall influence in addition to bridging the PTSS and personality domains. In the network with all variables of interest, the PTG domain of new possibilities was the strongest overall influence on the network. Specific relationships between constructs were identified.
Limitations of this study include the cross-sectional design and utilization of a sub-threshold PTSD, non-treatment seeking sample.
Overall, nuanced relationships between variables of interest were identified, informing personalized treatment and furthers our understanding of both positive and negative responses to trauma. As the primary influence across two networks, the experience of strong negative emotions appears to be central to the subjective experience of PTSD. This may indicate a need to modify present treatments for PTSD, which conceptualize PTSD as a primarily fear-based disorder.
经历创伤性事件后,可能会出现两种结果,即经历创伤后成长(PTG),和/或表现出创伤后应激症状(PTSS)的困扰。这两个结构并非相互排斥;那些经历 PTSS 的人可能会同时或在稍后经历 PTG。创伤前因素,如大五人格量表(BFI)所衡量的人格,会与 PTSS 和 PTG 相互作用。
本研究利用网络理论,对 1310 名参与者的 PTSS、PTG 和人格之间的相互作用进行了研究。计算了三个网络(PTSS、PTSS/BFI、PTSS/PTG/BFI)。
在 PTSS 网络中,强烈的负面情绪是对网络影响最大的因素。同样,在 PTSS 和 BFI 网络中,强烈的负面情绪除了连接 PTSS 和人格领域外,还对网络产生了最强的整体影响。在包含所有感兴趣变量的网络中,PTG 领域的新可能性对网络产生了最强的整体影响。确定了结构之间的具体关系。
本研究的局限性包括横断面设计和使用亚阈值 PTSD、非治疗寻求样本。
总体而言,确定了感兴趣变量之间的细微关系,为个性化治疗提供了信息,并进一步加深了我们对创伤后积极和消极反应的理解。作为两个网络中的主要影响因素,强烈的负面情绪的体验似乎是 PTSD 的主观体验的核心。这可能表明需要修改目前的 PTSD 治疗方法,目前的 PTSD 治疗方法将 PTSD 概念化为主要基于恐惧的疾病。