Ijaz Nadine, Zhang Qi, Welsh Sandy, Boon Heather
Department of Law and Legal Studies, Carleton University, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.
Institute of Health Policy, Management and Evaluation, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Physiother Can. 2022 Jan 7;74(3):306-315. doi: 10.3138/ptc-2020-0116. eCollection 2022 Aug.
Physiotherapists practise various forms of acupuncture worldwide, but no international consensus exists as to the appropriate duration of related training programs. In this cross-sectional study, we aimed to characterize the training-related backgrounds and views of acupuncture-practising physiotherapists. A total of 426 physiotherapists who practised acupuncture in Ontario completed an online survey that included training-related items and an open-ended question (39 provided training-related responses). Statistical analyses included multivariate and multinomial logistical regression models. Thematic analysis was used to interpret respondents' textual responses to the open-ended question. Respondents, who practised predominantly Western medical acupuncture, dry needling, or both, had completed acupuncture-related training programs ranging from < 25 to ≥ 300 hours. Those who had completed programs lasting > 100 hours were significantly more likely to self-report excellent clinical results and an enhanced ability both to recruit and retain patients and to earn a higher income. They were also more likely to endorse longer trainings as necessary for safe and effective patient care. Respondents to the open-ended question expressed a range of views, including the need for more stringent training requirements. PT regulatory requirements for longer (>100 hour) acupuncture trainings may better support clinical effectiveness and safety, patient satisfaction, and professional outcomes.
物理治疗师在全球范围内开展各种形式的针灸治疗,但对于相关培训项目的适当时长,尚未达成国际共识。在这项横断面研究中,我们旨在描述从事针灸治疗的物理治疗师与培训相关的背景和观点。共有426名在安大略省从事针灸治疗的物理治疗师完成了一项在线调查,该调查包括与培训相关的项目和一个开放式问题(39人提供了与培训相关的回答)。统计分析包括多变量和多项逻辑回归模型。主题分析用于解释受访者对开放式问题的文字回答。主要采用西医针灸、干针疗法或两者兼用的受访者,完成的针灸相关培训项目时长从不足25小时到≥300小时不等。那些完成时长超过100小时培训项目的人,更有可能自我报告取得了出色的临床效果,以及在招募和留住患者及获得更高收入方面能力有所增强。他们也更有可能认可更长时间的培训对于安全有效的患者护理是必要的。对开放式问题的受访者表达了一系列观点,包括需要更严格的培训要求。物理治疗师监管机构对更长时间(>100小时)针灸培训的要求,可能会更好地支持临床有效性和安全性、患者满意度以及专业成果。