Department of Medicine, University of Colorado, Anschutz Medical Campus, Aurora.
Division of Renal Diseases and Hypertension, University of Colorado, Anschutz Medical Campus, Aurora.
JAMA Netw Open. 2023 Jun 1;6(6):e2319277. doi: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2023.19277.
Most undocumented immigrants with kidney failure rely on emergency dialysis (defined as dialysis after a patient presents as critically ill) and experience significant depression and anxiety and high mortality. Culturally and language-concordant peer support group interventions may be associated with reduced depression and anxiety and may provide emotional support.
To investigate the feasibility and acceptability of a single-group peer support group intervention.
DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This qualitative and single-group prospective study for undocumented immigrants with kidney failure receiving emergency dialysis was conducted in Denver, Colorado, from December 2017 to July 2018. The 6-month intervention included peer support group meetings in the hospital while participants were hospitalized for emergency dialysis. Data were analyzed from March to June 2022.
To assess feasibility, the recruitment, retention, implementation, and delivery for the intervention were tracked. To measure acceptability, interviews were conducted with participants using a structured format. To assess the value of the peer support group intervention, themes and subthemes were identified from interviews with participants and group meetings.
Of 27 undocumented immigrants with kidney failure receiving emergency dialysis, 23 participants (9 females [39.1%] and 14 males [60.9%]; mean [SD] age, 47 [8] years) agreed to participate (recruitment rate, 85.2%). Among them, 5 individuals withdrew and did not attend meetings and 18 participants (retention rate, 78.3%) attended a mean of 6 of 12 meetings (50.0%). From interviews and meetings, 3 themes, with associated subthemes, were identified: camaraderie and emotional support from peers (subthemes: peer support is vital for people newly diagnosed with kidney failure, safe space to build relationships and share hardship with peers, hospital setting for peer support is ideal, solidarity to survive and change policy, and sustainability of the peer support group), solutions to improve care and resilience (subthemes: self-advocacy, self-motivation and optimism, kidney disease education, emotional support from peers caregivers, and faith), and emotional and physical aspects of receiving emergency dialysis (subthemes: psychosocial and physical distress, mixed experiences with language-concordant care, emotional exhaustion from end-of-life conversations, and gratitude for clinicians).
This study found that peer support group intervention achieved feasibility and acceptability. The findings suggest that a peer support group may be a patient-centered strategy to build camaraderie and provide emotional support in kidney failure, especially for socially marginalized uninsured populations who report limited English proficiency.
大多数肾功能衰竭的无证移民依赖急诊透析(定义为患者病危时进行的透析),并经历明显的抑郁和焦虑,以及高死亡率。文化和语言一致的同伴支持小组干预可能与降低抑郁和焦虑有关,并可能提供情感支持。
研究单一小组同伴支持小组干预的可行性和可接受性。
设计、地点和参与者:这是一项针对接受急诊透析的肾功能衰竭无证移民的定性和单一小组前瞻性研究,于 2017 年 12 月至 2018 年 7 月在科罗拉多州丹佛市进行。该 6 个月的干预措施包括在医院进行同伴支持小组会议,同时参与者因急诊透析住院。数据于 2022 年 3 月至 6 月进行分析。
为评估可行性,跟踪了干预措施的招募、保留、实施和交付情况。为了衡量可接受性,使用结构化格式对参与者进行了访谈。为了评估同伴支持小组干预的价值,从参与者的访谈和小组会议中确定了主题和子主题。
在接受急诊透析的 27 名肾功能衰竭无证移民中,有 23 名参与者(9 名女性[39.1%]和 14 名男性[60.9%];平均[SD]年龄,47[8]岁)同意参加(招募率,85.2%)。其中,5 人退出且未参加会议,18 名参与者(保留率,78.3%)参加了 12 次会议中的 6 次(50.0%)。通过访谈和会议,确定了 3 个主题,以及相关的子主题:同伴之间的友情和情感支持(子主题:同伴支持对于新诊断为肾衰竭的人至关重要,在与同伴建立关系和分享困难时提供安全空间,在医院环境中提供同伴支持是理想的,为生存和改变政策而团结,以及同伴支持小组的可持续性),改善护理和韧性的解决方案(子主题:自我倡导、自我激励和乐观、肾病教育、来自同伴照顾者的情感支持、对临床医生的信仰),以及接受急诊透析的情感和身体方面(子主题:心理社会和身体困扰、与语言一致的护理体验混合、临终对话引起的情绪疲惫、对临床医生的感激)。
本研究发现,同伴支持小组干预达到了可行性和可接受性。研究结果表明,同伴支持小组可能是一种以患者为中心的策略,可以在肾衰竭中建立友情和提供情感支持,特别是对于社会边缘化的、没有保险的人群,他们报告英语水平有限。