European Federation of Nurses Associations, Ixelles, Brussels, Belgium.
Faculty of Nursing, Midwifery & Palliative Care, King's College London, London, UK.
Policy Polit Nurs Pract. 2023 Nov;24(4):255-264. doi: 10.1177/15271544231182586. Epub 2023 Jul 20.
We report the results of a mapping exercise by the European Federation of Nurses (EFN) on challenges and solutions related to violence against nurses. This is an issue of growing international concern, with the problem accentuated during and following the COVID-19 pandemic. Following a cross-sectional observational design, an online questionnaire was distributed among 35 national nurses' associations across Europe in March 2021. Face validity was achieved through an expert panel. Descriptive statistics were used for data analysis, including counts, percentages, and tabulation. Qualitative data analysis followed thematic synthesis techniques. Three main findings are noted. First, violent incidents against nurses are under-reported due to fear of victimization, employer discouragement, and the perception that reporting will not make any difference. Second, perpetrators of violent acts extend beyond patients and families to include health professionals of different ranks. Third, violent incidences have a significant adverse effect on nurses' health and retention, leading to nurses reducing their working hours or opting for part-time work. Violence against nurses is an expression of a broader problem that is rooted in the failure to recognize and manage violence at the level of the healthcare organization, and the absence of appropriate legislation to maintain minimum standards of safe working environments. This is partly the result of inadequate European Union-wide legislation targeting workplace violence in the health professions. Nurses need more institutional support through dedicated funding aimed at targeted interventions, more legislative commitment to ratify policies against discrimination, and an opportunity to voice the needs to the appropriate policymakers with the ability to bring significant change to existing conditions. Given the severity of the situation, inaction could lead to irreplaceable damage to the nursing workforce, compounding pressures resulting from the COVID-19 pandemic. Ultimately, this situation can further drive existing nurses out of the profession, weakening health systems worldwide.
我们报告了欧洲护士联合会(EFN)在与护士遭受暴力相关的挑战和解决方案方面所进行的一项映射研究的结果。这是一个日益受到国际关注的问题,在 COVID-19 大流行期间和之后,这个问题更加突出。采用横断面观察性设计,我们于 2021 年 3 月在欧洲的 35 个国家护士协会中分发了在线问卷。通过专家小组实现了表面效度。数据分析采用描述性统计,包括计数、百分比和制表。定性数据分析遵循主题合成技术。注意到三个主要发现。首先,由于害怕受害、雇主劝阻和认为报告无济于事,护士遭受暴力的事件报告不足。其次,暴力行为的实施者不仅限于患者和家属,还包括不同职级的卫生专业人员。第三,暴力事件对护士的健康和留职产生了重大的负面影响,导致护士减少工作时间或选择兼职工作。护士遭受暴力是一个更广泛问题的表现,其根源在于未能在医疗机构层面认识和管理暴力行为,以及缺乏适当的立法来维持安全工作环境的最低标准。这在一定程度上是由于欧盟范围内针对卫生专业人员工作场所暴力的立法不足所致。护士需要通过专门的资金获得更多的机构支持,以实施有针对性的干预措施,需要更多的立法承诺来批准反歧视政策,并为适当的决策者提供一个表达需求的机会,他们有能力为现有条件带来重大变化。鉴于情况的严重性,如果不采取行动,可能会对护理人员队伍造成不可替代的损害,加剧 COVID-19 大流行带来的压力。最终,这种情况可能会使现有护士进一步离开这个行业,削弱全球卫生系统。