Psychiatric Hospital, Government Hospitals, Manama, Bahrain; Department of Psychiatry, College of Medicine and Medical Sciences, Arabian Gulf University, Manama, Bahrain.
Department of Psychiatry, College of Medicine and Medical Sciences, Arabian Gulf University, Manama, Bahrain.
J Psychosom Res. 2023 Oct;173:111479. doi: 10.1016/j.jpsychores.2023.111479. Epub 2023 Aug 26.
Medical students frequently experience a range of stressors, such as demanding academic requirements, competition and rivalry, self-doubt, and financial distress. As a result, they are at risk for psychological and behavioral symptoms (PBS) including: depression, anxiety, and sleep difficulties as well as maladaptive substance use.
To determine the degree of risk for these symptoms, 13 databases, without language restriction., were searched.
A total of 32 meta-analyses were included in this umbrella review. A global analysis of all self-reported PBS combined yielded a pooled prevalence rate of 30.3% [26.9%; 33.7%]; 95% PI [2.2%; 58.3%]. The highest reported prevalence was for sleep problems 42.0% [35.6%; 48.4%], followed by stress 41.7% [35.3%; 48.1%], burnout 35.8% [25.7%; 45.8%], anxiety 32.5% [27.9%; 37.1%], depression 32.5% [28.8%; 36.1%], internet addiction 26.0% [5.5%; 46.5%], substance use 25.2% [18.9%; 31.6%], eating disorders 9.8% [1.1%; 18.4%], and suicidal thoughts/gestures/acts 8.9% [4.8%; 12.9%]. The prevalence estimates were deemed acceptable for all PBS.
The evidence shows that fully one-third of medical students experience a range of problematic PBS, likely attributable to the demanding and intense study environment, the hierarchical structure of medical training facilities, and the vulnerability of the young adulthood time period. Appropriately targeted assessment and intervention efforts are clearly warranted to decrease the psychological burden of medical student training. PROSPERO Identifier: CRD42023391800. Open Science Network (OSF) Identifier: DOI 10.17605/OSF.IO/SXQYN.
医学生经常面临各种压力源,如苛刻的学术要求、竞争和敌对、自我怀疑和经济困难。因此,他们面临心理和行为症状(PBS)的风险,包括:抑郁、焦虑和睡眠困难以及适应不良的物质使用。
为了确定这些症状的风险程度,我们搜索了 13 个数据库,没有语言限制。
这项伞式综述共纳入了 32 项荟萃分析。对所有自我报告的 PBS 进行综合分析,得出的综合患病率为 30.3%[26.9%;33.7%];95%PI[2.2%;58.3%]。报告的最高患病率是睡眠问题 42.0%[35.6%;48.4%],其次是压力 41.7%[35.3%;48.1%]、倦怠 35.8%[25.7%;45.8%]、焦虑 32.5%[27.9%;37.1%]、抑郁 32.5%[28.8%;36.1%]、网络成瘾 26.0%[5.5%;46.5%]、物质使用 25.2%[18.9%;31.6%]、饮食失调 9.8%[1.1%;18.4%]和自杀想法/手势/行为 8.9%[4.8%;12.9%]。所有 PBS 的患病率估计均被认为是可以接受的。
证据表明,完全有三分之一的医学生经历了一系列有问题的 PBS,这可能归因于苛刻和紧张的学习环境、医学培训设施的等级结构以及青年期的脆弱性。显然需要有针对性的评估和干预措施,以减轻医学生培训的心理负担。PROSPERO 标识符:CRD42023391800。开放科学网络(OSF)标识符:DOI 10.17605/OSF.IO/SXQYN。