Youn Bo-Young, Cha Jie-Won, Cho Sungsu, Jeong So-Mi, Kim Hyo-Jung, Ko Seong-Gyu
Department of Preventive Medicine, College of Korean Medicine, Kyung Hee University, Seoul, South Korea.
Department of Applied Korean Medicine, Graduate School, Kyung Hee University, Seoul, South Korea.
Cancer Med. 2023 Sep;12(18):19149-19162. doi: 10.1002/cam4.6499. Epub 2023 Sep 7.
With the rapid increase in the prevalence of cancer worldwide, the utilization of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) has increased among cancer patients. This review aimed to understand the perception, attitudes, and knowledge of healthcare professionals toward using CAM for cancer patients.
A mixed-methods systematic review was undertaken in four databases. Inclusion criteria were primary studies reporting perception, attitudes, and knowledge of healthcare professionals for using CAM for cancer patients were eligible. A mixed-methods convergent synthesis was carried out, and the findings were subjected to a GRADE-CERQual assessment of confidence.
Forty-two studies were chosen. The majority of the studies were quantitative and had less than 100 participants. Most publications were from European countries, and oncology was the highest among the specialties. The review found the following themes: feasibility of having negative adverse effects, low expectations of using CAM among HCPs, potential positive effects of using CAM, specific CAM training may be helpful, no concrete regulations to promote CAM practice, and poor physician-patient communication.
Nurses had more positive views than other professions; oncologists were concerned regarding herb-drug interactions; integration of CAM into the healthcare system was favorable; HCPs felt the need to participate in specific CAM training; and HCPs agreed that CAM education should be provided more regularly. Future studies should explore the studies views of cancer patients and details of in-depth evidence of CAM in oncology settings.
随着全球癌症患病率的迅速上升,癌症患者对补充和替代医学(CAM)的使用有所增加。本综述旨在了解医护人员对癌症患者使用CAM的认知、态度和知识。
在四个数据库中进行了混合方法的系统综述。纳入标准为报告医护人员对癌症患者使用CAM的认知、态度和知识的原始研究。进行了混合方法的收敛性综合分析,并对研究结果进行了GRADE-CERQual信心评估。
共选择了42项研究。大多数研究是定量研究,参与者少于100人。大多数出版物来自欧洲国家,肿瘤学是各专业中占比最高的。综述发现了以下主题:存在负面不良反应的可行性、医护人员对使用CAM的期望较低、使用CAM的潜在积极作用、特定的CAM培训可能会有帮助、促进CAM实践没有具体规定以及医患沟通不良。
护士比其他职业有更积极的看法;肿瘤学家担心草药与药物的相互作用;将CAM整合到医疗保健系统中是有利的;医护人员感到有必要参加特定的CAM培训;医护人员一致认为应该更定期地提供CAM教育。未来的研究应该探索癌症患者的研究观点以及肿瘤学环境中CAM深入证据的细节。