Department of Biostatistics, University of Washington, Seattle, WA, 98195, USA.
Department of Population Health, Division of Biostatistics, New York University, New York, NY, USA.
Prev Sci. 2024 Jul;25(Suppl 3):348-355. doi: 10.1007/s11121-023-01587-1. Epub 2023 Sep 20.
The stepped wedge design is often used to evaluate interventions as they are rolled out across schools, health clinics, communities, or other clusters. Most models used in the design and analysis of stepped wedge trials assume that the intervention effect is immediate and constant over time following implementation of the intervention (the "exposure time"). This is known as the IT (immediate treatment effect) assumption. However, recent research has shown that using methods based on the IT assumption when the treatment effect varies over exposure time can give extremely misleading results. In this manuscript, we discuss the need to carefully specify an appropriate measure of the treatment effect when the IT assumption is violated and we show how a stepped wedge trial can be powered when it is anticipated that the treatment effect will vary as a function of the exposure time. Specifically, we describe how to power a trial when the exposure time indicator (ETI) model of Kenny et al. (Statistics in Medicine, 41, 4311-4339, 2022) is used and the estimand of interest is a weighted average of the time-varying treatment effects. We apply these methods to the ADDRESS-BP trial, a type 3 hybrid implementation study designed to address racial disparities in health care by evaluating a practice-based implementation strategy to reduce hypertension in African American communities.
阶梯式楔形设计通常用于评估在学校、诊所、社区或其他集群中推出的干预措施。在设计和分析阶梯式楔形试验中使用的大多数模型都假设干预效果是即时的,并且在实施干预措施后(“暴露时间”)随时间保持不变。这被称为 IT(即时治疗效果)假设。然而,最近的研究表明,当治疗效果随暴露时间而变化时,使用基于 IT 假设的方法会产生极其误导的结果。在本文中,我们讨论了当违反 IT 假设时需要仔细指定适当的治疗效果度量的必要性,并展示了当预计治疗效果将随暴露时间变化时如何为阶梯式楔形试验提供动力。具体来说,我们描述了当使用 Kenny 等人的暴露时间指标 (ETI) 模型(《统计医学》,第 41 卷,第 4311-4339 页,2022 年)时如何为试验提供动力,并且感兴趣的估计量是随时间变化的治疗效果的加权平均值。我们将这些方法应用于 ADDRESS-BP 试验,该试验是一项 3 型混合实施研究,旨在通过评估一种基于实践的实施策略来减少非洲裔美国人社区的高血压,从而解决医疗保健中的种族差异问题。