Environment and Plant Protection Institute, Chinese Academy of Tropical Agricultural Sciences, Haikou 571101, PR China; National Agricultural Experimental Station for Agricultural Environment, Danzhou 571737, PR China; Hainan Engineering Research Center for Non-point Source and Heavy Metal Pollution Control, Danzhou 571737, PR China.
Hainan Research Academy of Environmental Sciences, Haikou 571126, PR China.
Sci Total Environ. 2024 Jan 15;908:168270. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2023.168270. Epub 2023 Oct 31.
Rice-vegetable rotation practices prevail in subtropical and tropical agriculture worldwide, with applications of current-use herbicides (CUHs) vital for nontarget plant control. After application, CUHs migrate to environmental compartments, where the occurrence, fate, and ecological risks have not been well characterized. To further understand the occurrence and multiphase partitioning, as well as to evaluate potential drivers and mixture risks in environmental compartments, we analyzed 11 CUHs in 576 samples from 36 rice-vegetable rotations in Nandu River basin, Hainan, China. Samples included soil, water, suspended particulate matter, and sediment collected during both rice and vegetable planting periods. The CUH concentrations varied across environmental compartments, but with high levels of glyphosate and aminomethylphosphonic acid organophosphorus herbicides (OPHs) frequently detected, accounting for 82.3 % to 99.0 % in environmental compartments. Phenoxy acid (PAA) and chloroacetanilide (ANH) herbicides were detected at lower frequencies. Spatiotemporal variation was significantly different among OPHs, ANHs, and PAAs, with geographic and crop-related patterns most evident for CUHs rather than OPHs. Structural equation model, redundancy, and boosted regression tree analyses indicated environmental compartment properties (pH, organic matter, and Fe/Al oxides), crop type, and wet/dry climate were important drivers of spatiotemporal patterns. Fugacity ratios indicated multiphase partitioning and transport of CUHs differed in rice and vegetable planting periods. A new assessment framework based on species-sensitive distributions and environmental compartment weight index indicated unacceptable risks of CUHs (risk quotient >1 in >50 % of sites), with most risks from OPHs (10.5 % to 98.0 %) and butachlor, acetochlor, and 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid. Risk hot spots were identified as the soil, the central region, and the vegetable planting period, potentially threatening nontarget organisms (e.g., Lemna minor, Glomus intraradices, and Apis mellifera). This study provides a new risk assessment framework and demonstrates the domination of OPHs in CUH contamination and risks in the tropics, thus helping guide policymakers and stakeholders on herbicide management.
水稻-蔬菜轮作在世界范围内的亚热带和热带农业中普遍存在,当前使用的除草剂(CUHs)对于非靶标植物的控制至关重要。施用于农田后,CUHs 会迁移到环境介质中,而其在环境介质中的发生、归宿和生态风险尚未得到充分描述。为了进一步了解环境介质中的发生和多相分配情况,并评估其潜在的驱动因素和混合物风险,我们分析了来自中国海南南渡江流域 36 个水稻-蔬菜轮作区的 576 个样本中的 11 种 CUHs。这些样本包括在水稻和蔬菜种植期间采集的土壤、水、悬浮颗粒物和沉积物。CUHs 在不同环境介质中的浓度存在差异,但经常检测到高水平的草甘膦和氨甲基膦酸有机磷除草剂(OPHs),占环境介质中 82.3%至 99.0%。而苯氧羧酸(PAA)和氯乙酰胺(ANH)除草剂的检出频率较低。OPHs、ANHs 和 PAAs 的时空变化差异显著,其中 CUHs 的地理和作物相关模式比 OPHs 更为明显。结构方程模型、冗余分析和提升回归树分析表明,环境介质特性(pH 值、有机质和铁/铝氧化物)、作物类型和干湿气候是时空模式的重要驱动因素。逸度比表明 CUHs 在水稻和蔬菜种植期间存在多相分配和迁移。基于物种敏感分布和环境介质权重指数的新评估框架表明,CUHs 存在不可接受的风险(>50%的地点风险商数>1),其中大部分风险来自 OPHs(10.5%至 98.0%)和丁草胺、乙草胺和 2,4-二氯苯氧乙酸。风险热点是土壤、中部地区和蔬菜种植期,可能对非靶标生物(如浮萍、丛枝菌根真菌和蜜蜂)造成威胁。本研究提供了一个新的风险评估框架,并证明了 OPHs 在热带地区 CUH 污染和风险中的主导地位,从而有助于指导决策者和利益相关者进行除草剂管理。