Centre for Ethics and Law in the Life Sciences, Durham Law School, Durham University, Durham, UK
School of Law and Criminology, University of Greenwich, London, UK.
J Med Ethics. 2024 May 9;50(5):299-307. doi: 10.1136/jme-2023-109412.
In this paper, we explore how the prospect of artificial placenta technology (nearing clinical trials in human subjects) should encourage further consideration of the loss experienced by individuals when their pregnancy ends unexpectedly. Discussions of pregnancy loss are intertwined with procreative loss, whereby the gestated entity has died when the pregnancy ends. However, we demonstrate how pregnancy loss can and does exist separate to procreative loss in circumstances where the gestated entity survives the premature ending of the pregnancy. In outlining the value that can be attached to pregnancy beyond fetal-centric narratives, we illustrate how pregnancy loss, separate to procreative loss, can be experienced. This loss has already been recognised among parents who have experienced an unexpected early ending of their pregnancy, resulting in their child being cared for in neonatal intensive care unit. Artificial placentas, however, may exacerbate these feelings and make pregnancy loss (without procreative loss) more visible. We argue that pregnancy is an embodied state in which gestation is facilitated by the body but gestation itself should be recognised as a process-and one that could be separable from pregnancy. In demarcating the two, we explore the different ways in which pregnancy loss can be understood. Our objective in this paper goes beyond contributing to our philosophical understanding of pregnancy towards practical-orientated conclusions regarding the care pathways surrounding the artificial placenta. We make recommendations including the need for counselling and careful consideration of the language used when an artificial placenta is used.
在本文中,我们探讨了人工胎盘技术(即将在人体临床试验中进行)的前景应该如何鼓励人们进一步考虑个体在意外妊娠终止时所经历的损失。对妊娠损失的讨论与生殖损失交织在一起,即当妊娠结束时,妊娠的实体已经死亡。然而,我们展示了在妊娠的实体在妊娠提前结束的情况下幸存的情况下,妊娠损失如何以及确实可以独立于生殖损失而存在。在概述可以附加于以胎儿为中心的叙述之外的妊娠价值时,我们说明了如何体验与生殖损失分开的妊娠损失。在那些经历意外的早期妊娠终止并导致其孩子在新生儿重症监护病房接受治疗的父母中,已经认识到了这种损失。然而,人工胎盘可能会加剧这些感觉,并使妊娠损失(无生殖损失)更加明显。我们认为,妊娠是一种身体状态,妊娠是由身体促进的,但妊娠本身应该被视为一个过程——一个可以与妊娠分开的过程。在划定两者的界限时,我们探讨了理解妊娠损失的不同方式。我们本文的目标不仅仅是为了增进我们对妊娠的哲学理解,还包括围绕人工胎盘的护理途径提出实际导向的结论。我们提出了一些建议,包括需要咨询以及在使用人工胎盘时仔细考虑所用语言。