NIHR Evidence Synthesis Group @Complex Review Support Unit.
Department of Population Health Sciences, University of Leicester, Leicester, UK.
Age Ageing. 2023 Nov 2;52(11). doi: 10.1093/ageing/afad211.
Evidence synthesis, embedded within a systematic review of the literature, is a well-established approach for collating and combining all the relevant information on a particular research question. A robust synthesis can establish the evidence base, which underpins best practice guidance. Such endeavours are frequently used by policymakers and practitioners to inform their decision making. Traditionally, an evidence synthesis of interventions consisted of a meta-analysis of quantitative data comparing two treatment alternatives addressing a specific and focussed clinical question. However, as the methods in the field have evolved, especially in response to the increasingly complex healthcare questions, more advanced evidence synthesis techniques have been developed. These can deal with extended data structures considering more than two treatment alternatives (network meta-analysis) and complex multicomponent interventions. The array of questions capable of being answered has also increased with specific approaches being developed for different evidence types including diagnostic, prognostic and qualitative data. Furthermore, driven by a desire for increasingly up-to-date evidence summaries, living systematic reviews have emerged. All of these methods can potentially have a role in informing older adult healthcare decisions. The aim of this review is to increase awareness and uptake of the increasingly comprehensive array of newer synthesis methods available and highlight their utility for answering clinically relevant questions in the context of older adult research, giving examples of where such techniques have already been effectively applied within the field. Their strengths and limitations are discussed, and we suggest user-friendly software options to implement the methods described.
证据综合是一种将特定研究问题的所有相关信息进行整理和综合的方法,其被嵌入到文献系统评价中。这种方法是一种成熟的方法,可以建立证据基础,为最佳实践指南提供支持。这种努力经常被政策制定者和从业者用来为他们的决策提供信息。传统上,干预措施的证据综合包括对比较两种特定和聚焦临床问题的治疗选择的定量数据进行荟萃分析。然而,随着该领域方法的不断发展,特别是为了应对日益复杂的医疗保健问题,更先进的证据综合技术也得到了发展。这些技术可以处理考虑两个以上治疗选择的扩展数据结构(网络荟萃分析)和复杂的多组分干预措施。随着为不同类型的证据(包括诊断、预后和定性数据)开发特定方法,能够回答的问题范围也有所增加。此外,由于希望获得越来越最新的证据总结,实时系统评价也应运而生。所有这些方法都有可能在为老年人医疗保健决策提供信息方面发挥作用。本综述旨在提高对现有越来越全面的新型综合方法的认识和应用,并强调其在回答老年人研究中临床相关问题方面的实用性,举例说明了这些技术在该领域中已经得到了有效应用的情况。讨论了它们的优缺点,并建议了易于使用的软件选项来实施所描述的方法。