College of Arts, Humanities & Education, University of Derby, Derby, UK.
Duke School of Nursing, Duke University, Durham, NC, USA.
Support Care Cancer. 2023 Dec 16;32(1):30. doi: 10.1007/s00520-023-08225-0.
Review the literature to propose suggestions or recommendations for controlling nausea and vomiting through integrative and non-pharmacological treatments for the MASCC/ESMO 2023 update of its antiemetic guidelines.
The authors identified available systematic reviews and/or meta-analyses for 12 integrative therapies, including acupressure, acupuncture, auricular therapy, electrical stimulation of point PC6, ginger use (i.e., Zingiber officinale), guided imagery, hypnosis, inhalation aromatherapy, music therapy, food-based interventions, progressive muscle relaxation, and reflexology. Reviews were assessed for quality through the AMSTAR2 tool. A consensus committee reviewed recommendations as per MASCC/ESMO established processes.
Thirty-nine systematic reviews and/or meta-analyses were used. There were major methodological flaws for many of the trials used as the bases for the reviews. No recommendation for ingested ginger could be made because of conflicting evidence. Recommendations were possible for acupuncture/electroacupuncture treatments, food-based interventions, and progressive muscle relaxation training alone or combined with guided imagery. No recommendations could be reached for a number of food-based approaches, inhalation aromatherapy, hypnosis in adults, music therapy, and reflexology.
While a limited number of suggestions are provided, there is a need for significantly higher quality trials in many of the therapeutic approaches assessed, before stronger recommendations and a wider range of approaches are made.
通过综合和非药物治疗方法,为 MASCC/ESMO 2023 年止吐指南更新提出控制恶心和呕吐的建议或推荐。
作者确定了 12 种综合疗法(包括穴位按压、针灸、耳穴疗法、PC6 点电刺激、生姜使用[即姜黄]、引导意象、催眠、吸入芳香疗法、音乐疗法、基于食物的干预措施、渐进性肌肉松弛和反射疗法)的现有系统评价和/或荟萃分析。通过 AMSTAR2 工具评估了评价的质量。根据 MASCC/ESMO 建立的程序,共识委员会审查了建议。
使用了 39 项系统评价和/或荟萃分析。许多作为评价基础的试验存在重大方法学缺陷。由于证据相互矛盾,无法对摄入生姜提出建议。对于针灸/电针治疗、基于食物的干预措施以及单独或与引导意象结合的渐进性肌肉松弛训练,可以提出建议。对于许多基于食物的方法、吸入芳香疗法、成人催眠、音乐疗法和反射疗法,无法提出建议。
虽然提供了一些有限的建议,但在评估的许多治疗方法中,需要进行质量更高的试验,然后才能提出更强有力的建议和更广泛的方法。