Innovation Support Unit, Instituto de Investigación Marqués de Valdecilla-IDIVAL, 39011 Santander, Spain.
Clinical Pharmacology Service, Hospital Universitario Marqués de Valdecilla-IDIVAL, 39008 Santander, Spain.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2023 Dec 14;20(24):7179. doi: 10.3390/ijerph20247179.
To understand whether patient safety and human factors are considered in healthcare technology procurement, we analyzed the case of infusion pumps as their use critically affects patient safety. We reviewed infusion pump procurements in the Spanish Public Sector Procurement Database. Sixty-three batches in 29 tenders for supplying 12.224 volumetric and syringe infusion pumps and consumables for an overall budget of EUR 30.4 M were identified and reviewed. Concepts related to "ease of use" were identified in the selection requirements of 35 (55.6%) batches, as part of the criteria for the selection of pumps in 23 (36.5%) batches, related to "intuitiveness" in the selection requirements of 35 (55.6%) batches, and in the criteria in 10 (15.9%) batches. No method to evaluate the ease of use, intuitiveness, or usability was mentioned. A review of the procurement teams responsible for the evaluation of the tenders showed no reported human factors or patient safety expertise. We conclude that infusion pump procurement considers usability as a relevant criterion for selection. However, no human factor experts nor specific methods for evaluation of the technology in this field are usually defined. Potential room for refining the selection of healthcare technology to improve patient safety is detected.
为了了解在医疗技术采购中是否考虑了患者安全和人为因素,我们分析了输液泵的案例,因为它们的使用会严重影响患者安全。我们审查了西班牙公共部门采购数据库中的输液泵采购情况。共确定并审查了 29 份招标中的 63 批输液泵和注射器,共采购 12224 台输液泵和耗材,总预算为 3040 万欧元。在 35 批(55.6%)招标的选择要求中确定了与“易用性”相关的概念,作为 23 批(36.5%)泵选择标准的一部分,在 35 批(55.6%)招标的选择要求中与“直观性”相关,在 10 批(15.9%)招标的标准中与“直观性”相关。没有提到评估易用性、直观性或可用性的方法。对负责评估招标的采购团队的审查显示,没有报告人为因素或患者安全专业知识。我们的结论是,输液泵采购将可用性视为选择的一个相关标准。然而,通常没有人为因素专家或该领域技术评估的特定方法。为了提高患者安全性,发现了改进医疗技术选择的潜在空间。