Hamano Jun, Masukawa Kento, Tsuneto Satoru, Shima Yasuo, Morita Tatsuya, Kizawa Yoshiyuki, Miyashita Mitsunori
Department of Palliative and Supportive Care, Institute of Medicine, University of Tsukuba, Tsukuba, Ibaraki, Japan.
Department of Palliative Nursing, Health Sciences, Graduate School of Medicine, Tohoku University, Sendai, Miyagi, Japan.
Palliat Med Rep. 2023 Dec 22;4(1):350-357. doi: 10.1089/pmr.2023.0053. eCollection 2023.
Death pronouncement is an important moment that can impact a family's bereavement process; however, necessary improvements in physicians' behavior during death pronouncement remain unclear.
To explore whether the lack of certain behaviors by the physician was associated with a perceived need for improving death pronouncement for advanced cancer patients in palliative care units (PCUs).
This study was a secondary analysis of a nationwide multicenter questionnaire survey conducted in 2018 that targeted bereaved family members of cancer patients who died in PCUs. We performed univariate analysis to investigate the need to improve behavior toward death pronouncement. We performed bivariate analysis to investigate the relationship among the need for improvement in behavior toward death pronouncement, physician attribution (primary responsible physician, a member of the same team, and another physician), and nine specific behaviors.
Four hundred twenty-two questionnaires (64.2%) were returned. We analyzed 356 responses and found that 32.5% perceived the need to improve death pronouncement. Lack of certain behaviors at death pronouncement, especially not explicitly explaining the cause of death to family members (odds ratio: 11.89, < 0.001), were positively associated with the need for improvement. There were significant differences among the types of physician attribution regarding the need for improvement (primary responsible physician vs. a member of the same team vs. another physician [15.1% vs. 42.6% vs. 45.7%, < 0.001]).
There was a significant positive association between the lack of certain behaviors toward death pronouncement and the need for improvement. The major lack of behavior toward death pronouncement was not explicitly explaining the cause of death to family members and not calling out to the patient before beginning the patient's examination.
宣布死亡是一个重要时刻,可能会影响家庭的丧亲过程;然而,医生在宣布死亡时行为的必要改进仍不明确。
探讨医生缺乏某些行为是否与认为有必要改善姑息治疗病房(PCUs)中晚期癌症患者的死亡宣布有关。
本研究是对2018年进行的一项全国多中心问卷调查的二次分析,该调查针对在PCUs死亡的癌症患者的丧亲家庭成员。我们进行单因素分析以调查改善死亡宣布行为的必要性。我们进行双因素分析以调查改善死亡宣布行为的必要性、医生归属(主要负责医生、同一团队成员和另一名医生)与九种特定行为之间的关系。
共返回422份问卷(64.2%)。我们分析了356份回复,发现32.5%的人认为有必要改善死亡宣布。宣布死亡时缺乏某些行为,特别是没有向家庭成员明确解释死亡原因(比值比:11.89,<0.001),与改善的必要性呈正相关。在改善必要性方面,医生归属类型之间存在显著差异(主要负责医生与同一团队成员与另一名医生[15.1%对42.6%对45.7%,<0.001])。
宣布死亡时缺乏某些行为与改善的必要性之间存在显著正相关。宣布死亡时主要缺乏的行为是没有向家庭成员明确解释死亡原因,以及在开始检查患者之前没有呼唤患者。