Colombo Elisa, Regli Luca, Esposito Giuseppe, Germans Menno R, Fierstra Jorn, Serra Carlo, Sebök Martina, van Doormaal Tristan
Department of Neurosurgery, Clinical Neuroscience Center, Universität Zürich, Universitätsspital Zürich, Zurich, Switzerland.
Department of Neurosurgery, Clinical Neuroscience Center, Universitätsspital Zürich, Zurich, Switzerland.
Oper Neurosurg (Hagerstown). 2023 Dec 29;26(5):551-8. doi: 10.1227/ons.0000000000001033.
Mixed reality (MxR) benefits neurosurgery by improving anatomic visualization, surgical planning and training. We aim to validate the usability of a dedicated certified system for this purpose.
All cases prepared with MxR in our center in 2022 were prospectively collected. Holographic rendering was achieved using an incorporated fully automatic algorithm in the MxR application, combined with contrast-based semiautomatic rendering and/or manual segmentation where necessary. Hologram segmentation times were documented. Visualization during surgical preparation (defined as the interval between finalized anesthesiological induction and sterile draping) was performed using MxR glasses and direct streaming to a side screen. Surgical preparation times were compared with a matched historical cohort of 2021. Modifications of the surgical approach after 3-dimensional (3D) visualization were noted. Usability was assessed by evaluating 7 neurosurgeons with more than 3 months of experience with the system using a Usefulness, Satisfaction and Ease of use (USE) questionnaire.
One hundred-seven neurosurgical cases prepared with a 3D hologram were collected. Surgical indications were oncologic (63/107, 59%), cerebrovascular (27/107, 25%), and carotid endarterectomy (17/107, 16%). Mean hologram segmentation time was 39.4 ± 20.4 minutes. Average surgical preparation time was 48.0 ± 17.3 minutes for MxR cases vs 52 ± 17 minutes in the matched 2021 cohort without MxR (mean difference 4, 95% CI 1.7527-9.7527). Based on the 3D hologram, the surgical approach was modified in 3 cases. Good usability was found by 57% of the users.
The perioperative use of 3D holograms improved direct anatomic visualization while not significantly increasing intraoperative surgical preparation time. Usability of the system was adequate. Further technological development is necessary to improve the automatic algorithms and reduce the preparation time by circumventing manual and semiautomatic segmentation. Future studies should focus on quantifying the potential benefits in teaching, training, and the impact on surgical and functional outcomes.
混合现实(MxR)通过改善解剖可视化、手术规划和培训,为神经外科手术带来益处。我们旨在验证为此目的而专门设计的认证系统的可用性。
前瞻性收集了2022年在我们中心使用MxR准备的所有病例。使用MxR应用程序中内置的全自动算法实现全息渲染,并在必要时结合基于对比度的半自动渲染和/或手动分割。记录全息图分割时间。手术准备期间(定义为最终麻醉诱导与无菌铺巾之间的间隔)的可视化使用MxR眼镜并直接流式传输到侧屏幕进行。将手术准备时间与2021年匹配的历史队列进行比较。记录三维(3D)可视化后手术入路的修改情况。通过使用“有用性、满意度和易用性(USE)”问卷对7名有超过3个月该系统使用经验的神经外科医生进行评估,以评估其可用性。
收集了107例使用3D全息图准备的神经外科病例。手术适应症包括肿瘤(63/107,59%)、脑血管(27/107,25%)和颈动脉内膜切除术(17/107,16%)。平均全息图分割时间为39.4±20.4分钟。MxR病例的平均手术准备时间为48.0±17.3分钟,而2021年未使用MxR的匹配队列平均手术准备时间为52±17分钟(平均差异4,95%CI 1.7527 - 9.7527)。基于3D全息图,3例手术入路发生了改变。57%的用户认为该系统可用性良好。
围手术期使用3D全息图可改善直接解剖可视化,同时不会显著增加术中手术准备时间。该系统的可用性足够。需要进一步的技术开发来改进自动算法,并通过避免手动和半自动分割来减少准备时间。未来的研究应侧重于量化在教学、培训方面的潜在益处以及对手术和功能结果的影响。