Teaching & Training Unit, Division of Infectious Diseases and Tropical Medicine, University Hospital, LMU, Munich, Germany.
Center for International Health, LMU, Munich, Germany.
BMC Pregnancy Childbirth. 2024 Jan 24;24(1):79. doi: 10.1186/s12884-023-06138-8.
Nepal is committed to achieving the Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) 2030 target 3.1 of reducing the maternal mortality ratio to 70 deaths per 100,000 live births. Along with increasing access to health facility (HF)-based delivery services, improving HF readiness is critically important. The majority of births in Nepal are normal low-risk births and most of them take place in public HFs, as does the majority of maternal deaths. This study aims to assess changes in HF readiness in Nepal between 2015 and 2021, notably, if HF readiness for providing high-quality services for normal low-risk deliveries improved; if the functionality of basic emergency obstetric and neonatal care (BEmONC) services increased; and if infection prevention and control improved.
Cross-sectional data from two nationally representative HF-based surveys in 2015 and 2021 were analyzed. This included 457 HFs in 2015 and 804 HFs in 2021, providing normal low-risk delivery services. Indices for HF readiness for normal low-risk delivery services, BEmONC service functionality, and infection prevention and control were computed. Independent sample T-test was used to measure changes over time. The results were stratified by public versus private HFs.
Despite a statistically significant increase in the overall HF readiness index for normal low-risk delivery services, from 37.9% in 2015 to 43.7%, in 2021, HF readiness in 2021 remained inadequate. The availability of trained providers, essential medicines for mothers, and basic equipment and supplies was high, while that of essential medicines for newborns was moderate; availability of delivery care guidelines was low. BEmONC service functionality did not improve and remained below five percent facility coverage at both time points. In private HFs, readiness for good quality obstetrical care was higher than in public HFs at both time points. The infection prevention and control index improved over time; however, facility coverage in 2021 remained below ten percent.
The slow progress and sub-optimal readiness for normal, low-risk deliveries and infection prevention and control, along with declining and low BEmONC service functionality in 2021 is reflective of poor quality of care and provides some proximate explanation for the moderately high maternal mortality and the stagnation of neonatal mortality in Nepal. To reach the SDG 2030 target of reducing maternal deaths, Nepal must hasten its efforts to strengthen supply chain systems to enhance the availability and utilization of essential medicines, equipment, and supplies, along with guidelines, to bolster the human resource capacity, and to implement mechanisms to monitor quality of care. In general, the capacity of local governments to deliver basic healthcare services needs to be increased.
尼泊尔致力于实现可持续发展目标(SDG)2030 年 3.1 目标,即把产妇死亡率降至每 10 万例活产死亡 70 人。除了增加获得医疗设施(HF)分娩服务的机会,提高 HF 准备情况至关重要。尼泊尔的大多数分娩为正常低风险分娩,其中大多数发生在公立 HF,产妇死亡也大多数发生在公立 HF。本研究旨在评估 2015 年至 2021 年期间尼泊尔 HF 准备情况的变化,特别是:HF 为正常低风险分娩提供高质量服务的准备情况是否有所改善;基本产科和新生儿急救服务(BEmONC)的功能是否增强;感染预防和控制是否有所改善。
对 2015 年和 2021 年两次基于 HF 的全国代表性调查的横断面数据进行了分析。这包括 2015 年的 457 家 HF 和 2021 年的 804 家提供正常低风险分娩服务的 HF。计算了 HF 为正常低风险分娩服务、BEmONC 服务功能和感染预防与控制的准备情况指数。采用独立样本 T 检验来衡量随时间的变化。结果按公立和私立 HF 进行分层。
尽管 2015 年至 2021 年期间,HF 为正常低风险分娩服务的整体准备情况指数从 37.9%上升至 43.7%,具有统计学意义,但 2021 年的 HF 准备情况仍然不足。熟练提供者、产妇基本药物、基本设备和用品的供应情况很高,而新生儿基本药物的供应情况中等;分娩护理指南的供应情况很低。BEmONC 服务功能没有改善,两个时间点的设施覆盖率均低于 5%。在私立 HF,两个时间点的高质量产科护理准备情况均高于公立 HF。感染预防和控制指数随时间推移而提高;然而,2021 年的设施覆盖率仍低于 10%。
正常低风险分娩和感染预防与控制方面进展缓慢,准备情况不佳,2021 年 BEmONC 服务功能下降且处于低水平,反映出护理质量较差,并为尼泊尔产妇死亡率中等偏高和新生儿死亡率停滞不前提供了一些直接原因。为实现 2030 年 SDG 降低产妇死亡率的目标,尼泊尔必须加快努力,加强供应链系统,提高基本药物、设备和用品以及指南的供应和利用,加强人力资源能力,并实施监测护理质量的机制。总体而言,需要增强地方政府提供基本医疗服务的能力。