The Public Health Agency of Canada, Ottawa, ON, Canada.
The Ottawa Hospital Research Institute, Ottawa, ON, Canada.
Age Ageing. 2024 Apr 1;53(4). doi: 10.1093/ageing/afae059.
Advancing health equity requires more contextualised evidence.
To synthesise published evidence using an existing framework on the origins of health disparities and determine care-related outcome disparities for residents of long-term care, comparing minoritised populations to the context-specific dominant population.
Systematic review.
Residents of 24-hour long-term care homes.
The protocol was registered a priori with PROSPERO (CRD42021269489). Literature published between 1 January 2000 and 26 September 2021, was searched, including studies comparing baseline characteristics and outcomes in minoritised versus dominant populations. Dual screening, two-reviewer verification for extraction, and risk of bias assessments were conducted to ensure rigour. Studies were synthesized using a conceptual framework to contextualise evidence according to multi-level factors contributing to the development of care disparities.
Twenty-one of 34 included studies demonstrated disparities in care outcomes for minoritised groups compared to majority groups. Thirty-one studies observed differences in individual-level characteristics (e.g. age, education, underlying conditions) upon entry to homes, with several outcome disparities (e.g. restraint use, number of medications) present at baseline and remaining or worsening over time. Significant gaps in evidence were identified, particularly an absence of literature on provider information and evidence on the experience of intersecting minority identities that contribute to care-related outcome disparities in long-term care.
This review found differences in minoritised populations' care-related outcomes. The findings provide guidance for future health equity policy and research-supporting diverse and intersectional capacity building in long-term care.
推进健康公平需要更多基于背景的证据。
利用现有的健康差异起源框架综合已发表的证据,并确定长期护理居民的与护理相关的结果差异,将少数群体与特定背景下的主流群体进行比较。
系统综述。
24 小时长期护理院的居民。
该方案在 PROSPERO(CRD42021269489)上预先注册。检索了 2000 年 1 月 1 日至 2021 年 9 月 26 日期间发表的文献,包括比较少数群体与主流群体之间基线特征和结果的研究。采用双重筛选、两位审稿人验证提取和偏倚风险评估来确保严谨性。根据导致护理差异发展的多层次因素,使用概念框架对证据进行综合,以使其背景化。
21 项纳入研究显示,少数群体与多数群体相比,在护理结果方面存在差异。31 项研究观察到入住养老院时个体特征(如年龄、教育、潜在疾病)的差异,并且在基线存在一些结果差异(如使用约束、用药数量),随着时间的推移,这些差异仍然存在或恶化。研究结果存在显著差距,特别是缺乏关于提供者信息的文献,以及关于导致长期护理中与护理相关的结果差异的交叉少数群体身份的经验的证据。
本综述发现少数群体在护理相关结果方面存在差异。研究结果为未来的健康公平政策和研究提供了指导,支持长期护理中多样化和交叉能力建设。