University Hospitals Cleveland Medical Center, Cleveland, OH 44106, USA.
School of Medicine, Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, OH 44106, USA.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2024 Apr 29;21(5):569. doi: 10.3390/ijerph21050569.
Remote and hybrid modes of instruction were employed as alternatives to in-person instruction as part of early mitigation efforts in response to the COVID-19 pandemic. We investigated the impact of a public school district's instructional mode on cumulative incidence and transmission in the surrounding community by employing a generalized estimating equations approach to estimate the association with weekly COVID-19 case counts by zip code in Cuyahoga County, Ohio, from August to December 2020. Remote instruction only (RI) was employed by 7 of 20 school districts; 13 used some non-remote instruction (NRI) (2-15 weeks). Weekly incidence increased in all zip codes from August to peak in late fall before declining. The zip code cumulative incidence within NRI school districts was higher than in those offering only RI (risk ratio = 1.12, = 0.01; risk difference = 519 per 100,000, 95% confidence interval (123-519)). The mean effect for NRI on emergent cases 2 weeks after mode exposure, controlling for Social Vulnerability Index (SVI), was significant only for high SVI zip codes 1.30, < 0.001. NRI may be associated with increased community COVID-19 incidence, particularly in communities with high SVI. Vulnerable communities may need more resources to open schools safely.
远程和混合教学模式被用作替代面对面教学的方式,作为应对 COVID-19 大流行的早期缓解措施的一部分。我们通过使用广义估计方程方法来研究一个公立学区的教学模式对周围社区累积发病率和传播的影响,该方法估计了俄亥俄州凯霍加县 2020 年 8 月至 12 月按邮政编码划分的 COVID-19 病例每周计数与每周 COVID-19 病例计数之间的关联。20 个学区中有 7 个采用了仅远程教学模式(RI);13 个使用了一些非远程教学模式(NRI)(2-15 周)。所有邮政编码的每周发病率从 8 月开始增加,在秋季末达到峰值后下降。在提供 NRI 的学区内的邮政编码累积发病率高于仅提供 RI 的学区(风险比=1.12, =0.01;风险差异=519/100,000,95%置信区间(123-519))。在考虑社会脆弱性指数(SVI)后,NRI 对暴露模式后 2 周出现的新发病例的平均影响仅在 SVI 较高的邮政编码中显著(1.30, <0.001)。NRI 可能与社区 COVID-19 发病率增加有关,尤其是在 SVI 较高的社区。弱势社区可能需要更多资源来安全地开放学校。