Centre for Nursing and Midwifery Research, James Cook University, 1 James Cook Drive, Douglas, Qld 4811, Australia.
Rural Remote Health. 2024 Jun;24(2):8721. doi: 10.22605/RRH8721. Epub 2024 Jun 21.
Maternity unit closures in rural and remote settings of Australia have left a substantial gap in services for pregnant women. In the absence of midwives, and when women are unable to attend a maternity facility, registered nurses (RNs) are required to fill the void. While maternity education can attempt to prepare RNs for such encounters, there is little documented to suggest it meets all their physical and psychological needs. The existing challenges for health professionals, practising a vast generalist scope of practice while living and working in a rural and remote location, have been well researched and documented. How nurses feel about the expectation that they work outside their scope of practice to provide maternity care in a rural and remote setting in Australia has not been asked until now. This study explores the perceptions and experiences of RNs who find themselves in this situation.
The study utilised a hermeneutic phenomenological methodology to examine the experiences and perceptions of rural and remote nurses providing care for pregnant women. RNs working in rural and remote health facilities that had no maternity services were recruited by a purposive sampling method. Semistructured conversational interviews were recorded and transcribed verbatim. Data analysis was guided by van Manen's analytical approach.
Eight nurses participated, and from the data three themes, each with several subthemes, emerged: 'being-in-the-world of the rural and remote nurse' - described how participants viewed rural and remote nursing as an entity with unchangeable aspects that could not be considered in isolation; 'scope of practice - unprepared or underprepared' described how, despite their existing and extensive nursing skills, participants felt ill-equipped theoretically, practically and mentally to care for pregnant women; 'moral distress' - participants expanded their feelings of unpreparedness to include inadequacy, fear, and appropriateness of care delivery.
The realism of rural and remote nursing practice demonstrates that at some point in their career, rural and remote nurses will care for a labouring and/or pregnant woman at high risk for complications. Participants in this study appeared open and honest in their interviews, displaying pride at their extensive nursing skills and job satisfaction. However, they were unanimous in their discussions of what being a nurse and providing maternity care in a rural and remote setting meant to themselves and to pregnant women. They suggested care was fragmented and inadequate from a workforce that is inadequately prepared and stressed.
This study has highlighted another concerning aspect of rural and remote midwifery care - the experiences and perceptions of eight nurses delivering care that has previously been overlooked. The united voice of the RNs in this study warrants a platform to speak from and deserves acknowledgement and attention from government and midwifery policy drivers. These nurses, and the women receiving their care, deserve more.
澳大利亚农村和偏远地区的产科病房关闭,导致孕妇服务出现了很大的缺口。在没有助产士的情况下,当妇女无法前往产科设施时,注册护士(RN)就需要填补这一空白。虽然产科学教育可以尝试让 RN 为这种情况做好准备,但几乎没有记录表明它满足了他们所有的身心需求。健康专业人员在农村和偏远地区生活和工作时,面临着巨大的通科实践范围的挑战,这些挑战已经得到了很好的研究和记录。到目前为止,还没有人询问过护士对在澳大利亚农村和偏远地区的这种情况下从事超出其实践范围的工作以提供产妇护理的期望有何感受。本研究探讨了在这种情况下工作的 RN 的看法和经验。
该研究采用解释学现象学方法,考察了在农村和偏远地区为孕妇提供护理的 RN 的经验和看法。通过目的性抽样方法,招募了在没有产科服务的农村和偏远地区卫生机构工作的 RN。对 RN 的半结构化对话式访谈进行了记录和逐字转录。数据分析遵循 van Manen 的分析方法。
共有 8 名护士参与,从数据中出现了三个主题,每个主题都有几个子主题:“农村和偏远地区护士的存在状态”-描述了参与者如何将农村和偏远地区的护理视为一个具有不可改变方面的实体,不能孤立地考虑;“实践范围-未准备或准备不足”-描述了尽管参与者拥有现有的广泛护理技能,但他们在理论、实践和心理上都觉得自己无法胜任照顾孕妇的工作;“道德困境”-参与者将他们的准备不足的感觉扩展到包括不足、恐惧和护理提供的适当性。
农村和偏远地区护理实践的现实性表明,在职业生涯的某个阶段,农村和偏远地区的护士将为高危产妇和/或孕妇提供护理。本研究中的参与者在访谈中表现出开放和诚实,对自己广泛的护理技能和工作满意度感到自豪。然而,他们在讨论自己作为护士和在农村和偏远地区提供产妇护理的意义时,意见一致。他们认为,从准备不足和压力大的劳动力那里获得的护理是分散和不足的。
本研究突出了农村和偏远地区助产护理的另一个令人担忧的方面--八名护士提供护理的经验和看法,这一点以前被忽视了。本研究中 RN 的一致声音需要一个发言的平台,并值得政府和助产政策制定者的认可和关注。这些护士和接受他们护理的妇女应该得到更多。