Garcia Kim, Mejia Pamela, Perez-Sanz Sarah, Dorfman Lori, Madsen Kristine, Schillinger Dean
Berkeley Media Studies Group, Berkeley, CA, United States.
School of Public Health, University of California, Berkeley, Berkeley, CA, United States.
Front Public Health. 2024 Jul 9;12:1390253. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2024.1390253. eCollection 2024.
To show how sugar-sweetened beverage (SSB) taxes were framed in posts on Twitter (now known as X) through text and images, we conducted a content analysis on a sample of Tweets from California users posted between January 1, 2015 and December 31, 2018 about SSB taxes in Berkeley, San Francisco, Oakland, and/or Albany, California. We evaluated posts for information sources, arguments for or against SSB tax policies, and images used. We found that posts presented a mix of messages through text and images. The majority of posts (64%) included arguments supporting SSB taxes, 28% presented a neutral position (e.g., factual information) or a mix of both pro-and anti-tax arguments, and 8% opposed. One-third of posts included an image, almost half of which appeared to be stock photos from SSB advertisements: many of these were shared by medical and public health users. Some tax supporters also reposted messages and images from opposition campaigns and added their own criticisms. By reposting opponents' anti-tax messages and images of SSBs, tax supporters may have inadvertently promoted SSBs, reinforced opposition to SSB taxes, and normalized SSBs. While advocates effectively shared pro-tax arguments, they should also ensure that accompanying images reflect the solutions they seek, not just the problem they are trying to combat.
为了展示含糖饮料(SSB)税在推特(现称X)上发布的帖子中是如何通过文字和图片呈现的,我们对2015年1月1日至2018年12月31日期间加利福尼亚州用户发布的关于加利福尼亚州伯克利、旧金山、奥克兰和/或奥尔巴尼的SSB税的推文样本进行了内容分析。我们评估了帖子的信息来源、支持或反对SSB税政策的论据以及所使用的图片。我们发现,帖子通过文字和图片呈现了多种信息。大多数帖子(64%)包含支持SSB税的论据,28%呈现中立立场(如事实信息)或支持和反对税收论据的混合,8%表示反对。三分之一的帖子包含一张图片,其中近一半似乎是来自SSB广告的库存照片:其中许多是由医学和公共卫生用户分享的。一些税收支持者还转发了反对派活动的信息和图片,并添加了自己的批评。通过转发反对者的反税信息和SSB图片,税收支持者可能无意中推广了SSB,强化了对SSB税的反对,并使SSB正常化。虽然倡导者有效地分享了支持税收的论据,但他们也应确保所附图片反映他们所寻求的解决方案,而不仅仅是他们试图解决的问题。