Faculty of Public Health and Policy, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, Keppel Street, LondonWC1E 7HT, England.
European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, London, England.
Bull World Health Organ. 2024 Aug 1;102(8):571-581. doi: 10.2471/BLT.23.290509. Epub 2024 Jun 10.
To assess national pandemic preparedness and response plans from a health system perspective to determine the extent to which implementation strategies that support health system performance have been included.
We systematically mapped pandemic preparedness and response implementation strategies that improve resilience to pandemics onto the Health System Performance Assessment Framework for Universal Health Coverage. Using this framework, we conducted a document analysis of 14 publicly available national influenza pandemic preparedness plans, submitted to the European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control, to assess how well health system functions are accounted for in each plan.
Implementation strategies found in national influenza pandemic preparedness plans do not systematically consider all health system functions. Instead, they mostly focus on specific aspects of governance. In contrast, little to no mention is made of implementation strategies that aim to strengthen health financing. There was also a lack of implementation strategies to strengthen the health workforce, ensure availability of medical equipment and infrastructure, govern the generation of resources and ensure delivery of public health services.
While national influenza pandemic preparedness plans often include provisions to support health system governance, implementation strategies that support other health system functions, namely, resource generation, service delivery, and in particular, financing, are given less attention. These oversights in key planning documents may undermine health system resilience when public health emergencies occur.
从卫生系统角度评估国家大流行防备和应对计划,以确定支持卫生系统绩效的实施策略的涵盖程度。
我们系统地将改善大流行应对韧性的防备和应对实施策略映射到全民健康覆盖卫生系统绩效评估框架上。使用该框架,我们对向欧洲疾病预防控制中心提交的 14 份公开的国家流感大流行防备计划进行了文件分析,以评估每个计划中卫生系统功能的涵盖情况。
国家流感大流行防备计划中的实施策略并没有系统地考虑所有卫生系统功能。相反,它们主要侧重于治理的具体方面。相比之下,几乎没有提及旨在加强卫生筹资的实施策略。也很少提及旨在加强卫生人力、确保医疗设备和基础设施的供应、管理资源的产生以及确保公共卫生服务提供的实施策略。
虽然国家流感大流行防备计划通常包括支持卫生系统治理的规定,但支持其他卫生系统功能(即资源产生、服务提供,特别是筹资)的实施策略却没有得到那么多的关注。这些在关键规划文件中的疏忽可能会在发生公共卫生紧急情况时削弱卫生系统的应对能力。